Wednesday, June 30, 2021

Today by Rachel Withers

States of disarray
Premiers have distanced themselves from the PM’s AstraZeneca call, but one state has taken its criticisms too far

Image of Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk. Image via ABC News

Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk. Image via ABC News

Things have grown even murkier in the wake of the prime minister’s unforeseen announcement on opening AstraZeneca to under-40s, as states push back against the change, which looks more and more like the result of a slip-up. In today’s stream of press conferences, premiers distanced themselves from Scott Morrison’s apparent captain’s call, each confirming that the decision had not come out of national cabinet, and that Pfizer was still the preferred vaccine for under-60s as per the medical advice. But the premiers’ positions on young people having the AstraZeneca vaccine if they wanted it varied from “Ask your GP what’s right for you” to “Do not, under any circumstances, get that jab”. Queensland went the furthest, with officials making it clear they did not want young people getting AstraZeneca at all, in a reckless, alarmist, fearmongering display that may have done more to undermine vaccine confidence than even the federal government’s bumbling comments. Health Minister Greg Hunt, a man who has done his fair share of damage to AstraZeneca confidence, did the media rounds on behalf of the PM, whom we have not heard from since Monday’s announcement. Hunt continued to tie himself in knots on Sunrise, standing by Morrison’s eligibility change while simultaneously standing by the medical advice, which has not changed. If it’s true that Morrison flubbed the line about AstraZeneca being open to “all ages”, you have to feel for Hunt, who is trying to protect the prime minister while also promoting the medical recommendations while not allowing this confounding error to contribute further to vaccine hesitancy.

There were no such qualms from the Queensland government, which came out first and hardest against the federal government, revealing that the state’s requests for more Pfizer had been denied, and suggesting that the PM had perhaps made the decision to open AstraZeneca eligibility to under-40s because mRNA supplies were running dry. Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk confirmed (repeatedly) that national cabinet had nothing to do with the AstraZeneca decision, and asked the PM to confirm where it had come from: “I’d like to ask the prime minister, did his cabinet make that decision?” Wouldn’t we all. But Palaszczuk and her team went even further, making it clear they did not want under-40s getting AstraZeneca at all, and talking up the risks to a dangerous level. Deputy Premier Steven Miles said the state-run hubs would not be providing AstraZeneca to under-40s, accusing the PM of putting people at risk, while Chief Health Officer Jeannette Young said they did not want under-40s getting AstraZeneca, pointing to the 49 deaths in the UK. “I don’t want an 18-year-old in Queensland dying from a clotting illness who, if they got COVID, probably wouldn’t die,” she said. “Wouldn’t it be terrible [if] our first 18-year-old in Queensland who dies related to this pandemic, died because of the vaccine?” The fear-stoking comments have prompted immediate backlash, with former federal deputy chief medical officer Dr Nick Coatsworth tweeting that Young’s comments put her “at odds” with him, as he warned against being paternalistic about the very small AstraZeneca risks. The comments, aimed first and foremost at scoring political points against the federal government, may have gone too far in scaring not just young people but also the already apprehensive over-60s, for whom AstraZeneca is recommended. It’s a cohort that needs to get vaccinated if Australia is to get out of its precarious state any time soon, and they need to be vaccinated with what is currently widely available.

Other states took a more measured approach in criticising the federal government’s decision, pointing to the official health advice (which recommends Pfizer as the “preferred” vaccine for young people), but without harping on about the blood clots and death associated with AstraZeneca. NSW, Victoria and Western Australia all confirmed that they would not be administering AstraZeneca to under-60s at state-run clinics either, meaning that under-60s need to see a GP to access the jab and properly discuss the risks. But the premiers all took slightly different stances when asked whether young people should get the AstraZeneca vaccine. WA Premier Mark McGowan said “It shouldn’t happen”, according to the health advice, noting slyly that the Commonwealth “has taken a different approach”. Victorian Health Minister Martin Foley recommended that under-60s who wanted it “go and see your GP and have a discussion about whether it is right for you”. NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian was, unsurprisingly, the least pointed in her criticism of her federal colleges, and avoided answering whether she believed young people should be able to get the AstraZeneca vaccine, with her chief health officer noting the importance of personal choice.

The Australian Medical Association, which yesterday refused to back the changed eligibility after being blindsided by the news, softened its position somewhat today, perhaps to avoid contributing to any hesitancy. President Dr Omar Khorshid told ABC News Breakfast that “we don’t have a problem removing restrictions that the prime minister has done” and that it was okay for younger people to receive AstraZeneca, “as long as they understand the risks associated”. But he continued to critique the lack of communication, and again called for a proper public health campaign “to change the general feeling around our vaccine program”.

The states were eager to communicate to citizens that the advice from the Australian Technical and Advisory Group on Immunisation surrounding AstraZeneca has not changed, and that their stance is that the ATAGI preference for Pfizer should still be followed. But there was a different tone to Queensland’s attacks, with their eagerness to capitalise on Morrison’s perceived blunder, even at the risk of doing much greater damage to the vaccine rollout, over a decision that many young people have welcomed. Of course, if this was a mistake on the part of Morrison, the best way for him to have sorted it out and avoided states turning to scaremongering would be to admit he made a mistake. That wouldn’t have dented confidence in the vaccine, though it would of course have dented confidence in him.

“The Archives has responsibility [for] both paper and digital. It’s essentially two archives, but it’s only ever had funding for one and that has reduced over the years.”

As if things weren’t bad enough for the National Archives of Australia, security experts warn the institution is at risk of cyber attack, with former chief information officer Anne Lyons saying its information isn’t thought of as valuable by policymakers.

“No one likes big holes in the ground … but the point is, you like your health system, you like your education system.”

Newly returned deputy prime minister Barnaby Joyce continues his predecessor’s habit of implying we won’t have schools without coal, arguing Australia needs coal power stations to bankroll services.

10 million Australians back in lockdown
In the past few days more than 10 million Australians have been plunged back into lockdowns, as fresh outbreaks of COVID-19 spread across major cities. The current crisis forced Prime Minister Scott Morrison to announce a radical overhaul to the vaccine rollout.


The number of commuter car park projects decided on by the PM the day before he called the 2019 election, at a cost of $389 million, despite an “inadequate assessment” of whether they were eligible. 

“A group of Australia’s biggest coal generators have roundly condemned proposed market rule changes favoured by federal energy minister Angus Taylor that are seen as an effective subsidy to ageing coal plants.”

In a submission to the Energy Security Board’s draft, AGL Energy (Australia’s biggest coal generation company) says the proposed changes have a “fundamental flaw”: they would protect existing generation but give no signal to new investment or new technologies.

The list

“Australia loves larrikins, as long as they are white, and polite, and display no flamboyance and voice no controversial opinions. Australia laments there is no colour in public life anymore, complains that sports-people show no personality in their interviews, and then punishes them the moment they do. Australia is willing to embrace Nick Kyrgios, as long as he becomes someone else.”

“There has never been such heightened community awareness about domestic abuse: what it looks like, how it feels and where to get help. This awareness is crucial: it not only helps victim-survivors identify the abuse earlier but can also give them the confidence to seek outside help. That more victim-survivors are seeking help is clear: family violence–related callouts to Victoria Police, for example, have increased significantly, from 65,000 in 2013–14 to 88,214 in 2019–20. Calls to the statewide family violence helpline, Safe Steps, have also risen sharply, from around 55,000 in 2014–15, to 74,000 last year. Awareness-raising is working.”

“Chronic pain affects a staggering one in five Australian adults. While it is accepted that pain should be managed in a holistic and overarching way, many patients just like Jenny wait up to a year and sometimes up to two years for appointments in public multidisciplinary pain clinics. In the meantime, these patients are left to seek care from general practitioners like me.”

Rachel Withers

Rachel Withers is the contributing editor of The Monthly Today.



The Monthly Today

Scott Morrison is welcomed to the US Capitol, by Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, September 22, 2021

Plus ça change

Morrison’s cackhandedness leaves him at the mercy of our allies, as French fury grows

Police watch protesters at Melbourne’s Shrine of Remembrance, Wednesday, September 22, 2021


Melbourne’s earthquake presages faultlines in the Coalition over ongoing lockdown protests

Strange bedfellows

The battlelines are blurring as Melbourne’s lockdown protests heat up

Nuclear fallout

The waves from Australia’s cancelled submarine contract keep building

From the front page

An anti-lockdown rally in Sydney, July 24, 2021

We need to think about post-lockdown rights

Lacking serious debate on the next stage of the pandemic, Australia is ill-prepared

Scott Morrison is welcomed to the US Capitol, by Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, September 22, 2021

Plus ça change

Morrison’s cackhandedness leaves him at the mercy of our allies, as French fury grows

Cover detail of Andrew O'Hagan’s ‘Mayflies’

There is a light

Andrew O’Hagan’s ‘Mayflies’ and what might endure from our irresponsible but spirited youth

Scott Morrison in the sheds after the NRL match between the Cronulla Sharks and the North Queensland Cowboys in Sydney, July 25, 2019

Birth of a larrikin

The disguised rise of Scott Morrison