The Politics    Wednesday, July 28, 2021

Pay as you go

By Rachel Withers

Pay as you go

Prime Minister Scott Morrison at a press conference today. Image via ABC News

With Morrison, help is gradual and insufficient

Once again, Prime Minister Scott Morrison has re-emerged to announce something mostly good, today caving to pressure to increase the ever-changing COVID-19 disaster payment and expand access to it. In an afternoon press conference full of tired Olympics puns and various extra business support announcements, Morrison revealed that the payment would increase to $750 per week for those who lost more than 20 hours of work (equal to JobKeeper levels, but it was not a return of JobKeeper, he insisted) and $450 for those who have lost less. There will also now be an additional $200 per week payment for people on welfare who have lost more than eight hours of work (not quite the level of the $275 JobSeeker supplement). The new amounts will apply from the start of any future lockdowns, with Morrison acknowledging it was now “clear” that locking down early was the best approach with Delta outbreaks. The PM’s announcement came just hours after NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian confirmed a four-week lockdown extension for Greater Sydney, along with a raft of changes to its settings. Morrison claimed that his changes were “necessary” in light of the extension – though surely if they are now to be applied from the start of lockdowns, it would have been “clear” that they were needed by stood-down workers all along. The PM was keen to impress upon Australians, and especially Sydneysiders, that “the Commonwealth government has your back”. But why does it only have your back weeks into a crisis, and after public pressure has grown impossible to ignore? Why does it always take Morrison so long to come to the income-support table? Why is it still a constant battle to get the federal government to do its job?

In announcing the changes, Morrison insisted the Coalition’s policies were “never set-and-forget” but were intended to be able to be adjusted on the ground – a ground over which he has been repeatedly dragged, kicking and screaming, to make such adjustments. Morrison was keen to argue that circumstances were changing because of the Delta variant, and so they are: the virus is clearly more infectious, in a way that the NSW and federal governments didn’t see coming. (It seems weird that the feds didn’t anticipate this, considering they banned Australians in India from coming home because of it.) “There’s no guidebook to COVID,” the PM said. “Even when you think you understand it, the Delta variant comes along and you’ve got to adjust.” But while the variant may have changed the need for lockdowns in Morrison’s eyes, it didn’t change the circumstances on the ground for those who were always in need of federal support – something the retroactive nature of these changes acknowledges. Morrison understands that locked-down people who cannot work need income assistance. But he was willing to treat them as pawns in his desperate bid not to “incentivise” state leaders to use such measures. Interestingly, he today repeated his recent insistence that lockdowns are the only way out of this, with “no other option” other than to hunker down.

In trumpeting his increased support (while insisting he didn’t care who “got the credit” for it), Morrison repeated many of the exact justifications that had been put to his government recently, only to be flatly rejected. You need to pay people enough to stay home, because you need them to stay home for the lockdown to work, he said. People on welfare who have lost hours do deserve this extra payment, he said, because they aren’t able to earn that extra income they were earning – a point that he only last week pushed back against, insisting this was not about “replacing” people’s income. (It’s also worth noting there are still no additional payments for people on welfare who haven’t lost work, even though they are now unlikely to find work, and would have been eligible for the original JobSeeker supplement – because apparently someone must always miss out.) But it wasn’t a complete backflip. The changes still didn’t go as far as many would have liked, with no return to a JobKeeper-type program – which NSW Treasurer Dominic Perrottet was still publicly pushing for this morning, in an opinion piece in The Daily Telegraph. While today’s changes do go some of the way towards addressing Perrottet’s calls (and those of industry groups, employers and unions, he notes), the system still doesn’t contain a mechanism to maintain the relationship between workers and employers, and it expires as soon as the Commonwealth-designated “hotspot” classification is removed, regardless of whether people are still on reduced hours. Morrison was at least consistent when asked about the JobKeeper calls, insisting his new program had more “agility” with the ability to be turned on and off as required; he even briefly forgot the Olympics and offered up a footy analogy: “You don’t play last year’s grand final.”

Nonetheless, credit should be given where credit’s due: today’s announcement is a welcome one, even if it doesn’t go far enough. But it’s only the latest in a long series of late and insubstantial changes the PM has made to his lockdown support package, after resisting calls to provide it at all. The payments were only introduced, after much begging and pleading and shaming, during Victoria’s fourth lockdown, and then were introduced very much on Morrison’s terms: $500 or $325 per week, kicking in only after seven days, and only for those with less than $10,000 in the bank. The assets test was waived from the third week when Sydney hit that mark, prompting cries of “PM for Sydney”. The amounts were then raised to $600 and $375 respectively, before being altered to apply from the first day of a lockdown, pro-rata, with no asset test at all.

Inch by inch, dollar by dollar, week by week, the PM has lifted income support back to the level it was under JobKeeper (for some), while refusing to simply bring back the program that proved to be such a wild success. Just once, it would be great to see the PM do something not because he is gradually pressured or shamed into it, or because the polls are bad, or because he wants to address the perception he has played favourites. If only he would do something because it’s the right thing to do.

“Across all of the vaccines, we said get as much as you can.”

Members of the government’s vaccine advisory group have responded to health secretary Brendan Murphy’s claim that COVID-19 vaccines were purchased on their advice. One member of the group said they urged the department to buy as many different vaccines as possible.

“This morning I was on Steve Bannon’s War Room…”

With the country in crisis, Senator Matt Canavan spent the morning being helpful by chatting with former Trump adviser Steve Bannon.

Welcome to the heat dome
Over the past few weeks, a slow-moving weather event has led to record high temperatures across North America. This kind of event is known as a heat dome, and it’s breaking existing models that try to predict the weather. Today, Max Opray on why this heat event is alarming climate scientists.

The size of the settlement the NT government has reached with young people who claim they were mistreated in youth detention, with the government losing its legal bid to suppress the payout figure.

“Federal Labor is set to swing the axe on its multibillion-dollar pledges for free cancer treatment and dental care for pensioners in an effort to slimline its election spending promises.”

The Opposition is walking away from its major health policies, just days after abandoning the progressive economic policies that would have funded them, leaving many asking: what is the point of Labor?

The list

“Mike White is all about the discreet harm of the bourgeoisie. The American writer and director specialises in portraying the delusions of his entitled compatriots, whether it’s the comfortable optimists who refuse to see the country’s fractures or the grasping hopefuls who mistake self-interest for self-improvement. White has long written Hollywood comedies, including 2003’s School of Rock, but in the last decade his humour has acquired a satirical sharpness – with the pratfalls replaced by pitfalls. His new HBO series, The White Lotus (Binge and Foxtel On Demand), is his most incisive work yet.”

“This is not a crime narrative, or a ghost story, although the novel takes some elements from both genres … The story is something else – a poetics of the body, and the way we expect it to hold definitions around gender, safety and identity. By taking Yun’s body away, Mills asks questions about who we are without our flesh, and how fragile our boundaries are.”

“Everyone who spoke to The Saturday Paper for this piece made one overarching observation: Kerry Chant is exactly the same in private as she is while addressing the state at the daily COVID-19 press conferences. Occasionally, however, she has joked with her colleagues and the other chief health and medical officers from across the country about the mind-boggling incompetence of some in power. The stories would make your eyes water, she says. But Chant is such a professional she will never tell them. At least, not for a while.”

Rachel Withers

Rachel Withers is the contributing editor of The Politics.


The Politics

Image of Anthony Albanese

Whither progress?

In a threatening climate, the first full year of the Albanese government has been defined by caution and incrementalism

6 News Australia interviews Gen Z Party founder Thomas Rex Dolan. Image via X.

Grift of the gab

Strange things are happening to our political system, and it’s time the major parties started paying attention

Voting results displayed on two large screens at the UN General Assembly’s tenth emergency special session

Ceaseless politics

The Albanese government calls for a ceasefire, and the Coalition goes on the attack

Image of Chris Bowen speaking at COP28

Not phased

What good are nice words about phasing out fossil fuels when Australia continues to expand and export?

From the front page

Kim Williams seen through window with arms half-raised

The interesting Mr Williams

At a time when the ABC faces more pressure than ever before, is its new chair the right person for the job?

Exterior of the Department of Treasury, Canberra

Tax to grind

Tax reform should not be centred on what we want, but on who we want to be

Rehearsal for the ABC TV show ‘Cooking with Wine’, March 13, 1956

Whose ABC?

Amid questions of relevance and culture war hostilities, the ABC’s charter clearly makes the case for a government-funded national broadcaster

Tony McNamara in New York City, January 2024

Pure things: Tony McNamara

How the Australian screenwriter of ‘Poor Things’, who cut his teeth on shows such as ‘The Secret Life of Us’, earnt his second Oscar nomination