Thursday, June 10, 2021

Today by Rachel Withers

Holding the line
Cracks are appearing in the Coalition’s immigration consensus

Image of Home Affairs Minister Karen Andrews

Home Affairs Minister Karen Andrews. Image via Twitter

It’s not clear what will happen to the family of four that has spent almost two years in detention on Christmas Island, but one thing is for sure: the Coalition is now in a state of turmoil over it, if determined to present a united front. Last night it was revealed that Liberal MPs were privately (though not publicly) pushing for the Biloela family to be moved to the mainland, as a candlelight vigil took place outside the Perth hospital where three-year-old Tharnicaa is being treated. Immigration Minister Alex Hawke – who is required to consider whether to “lift the bar” preventing her from applying for a visa – has reportedly received a formal submission from the family’s lawyers, and is considering his decision. But it’s obvious that attempts have been made to pull the troops into line. After a few days of hinting at resettlement, Home Affairs Minister Karen Andrews this morning did an inelegant job of walking back the “resettlement options” suggestion she made on Tuesday. Andrews told Sunrise the government was not considering resettlement options for the family, and said her earlier comment had been referring to those medevaced from Manus Island and Nauru – even though she was being asked about the family when she said it. “It was a very general comment in relation to cohorts that we have here in Australia,” she claimed, before returning to the government’s preferred messaging on the matter. “I am not going to have people dying trying to come to Australia by sea on my watch,” she said, echoing Attorney-General Michaelia Cash, who yesterday told a business event that people-smugglers “watch” Australia. The government, sadly, is recommitting to its hardline stance, at a time when support for the Biloela family appears to be the highest it’s ever been. But the cracks are beginning to show.

It’s difficult to believe that Andrews – whom many hoped would be more compassionate than her predecessor, Peter Dutton – was making a “general comment in relation to a range of cohorts” when she floated the settlement options during Tuesday’s Operation Ironside press conference, having been asked directly when the family would be released. At the time of the comment, Prime Minister Scott Morrison was quick to try to turn it into a general one, cutting in to say that it “applies across all cohorts, across all groups, not specifically” to the family, trying to shut down the idea before it picked up steam (“Yes,” Andrews hastily agreed). But the home affairs minister wasn’t the only one who hinted at resettlement for the family this week. Foreign Affairs Minister Marise Payne took Andrews’ words and ran with them on 2GB that afternoon, indicating that the US and New Zealand were being looked at as possible resettlement locations. “The United States and New Zealand are both in the frame,” she told the radio station. So, were two of Morrison’s most senior ministers wrong? It seems more likely they have been brought into line by the PM, with Morrison unwilling to have this issue progress while he is out of the country. It’s a shame the government has taken this path, especially at a time when – as even News Corp columnists note – it has a rare opportunity, and a reasonable excuse, to finally let the family go free.

The government, of course, would rather we stopped paying attention to its internal war over the Biloela family, and stay focused on the war it is intent on drumming up with China. Defence Minister Peter Dutton today addressed a conference run by the Australian Strategic Policy Institute (known for its anti-China sentiments), echoing his previous claims about the prospect of conflict being “less remote” than in the past, and that it was important to have a “frank and nuanced discussion” about it. The prime minister is soon leaving for the G7 summit in Europe (with a stopover in Singapore to discuss a potential travel bubble), but he made sure to beat the war drum on the way out the door, using yesterday’s big foreign policy speech to warn of the rising risk of conflict involving China. Beijing has “bristled” at Australia and Japan’s new joint statement on China’s aggressive economic “coercion”, with foreign ministry spokesperson Wang Wenbin accusing the two nations of “hyping up the so-called ‘China threat’”.

There is nothing this government loves more than hyping up a threat (to use Wang’s words), whether on China or people-smugglers or the risks of COVID, so long as it suits them to do so. After days of pressuring the Victorian government to end its lockdown (along with last week’s claims that he didn’t want to incentivise any overly cautious approaches by the states), Morrison has today turned – again – into the prime minister who “won’t take risks with Aussies’ lives”. When quizzed on Perth radio station 6PR over his refusal to set a date for the international border to reopen, Morrison noted that the United Kingdom, where he was headed, had 4000 cases per day. “If you’re suggesting that we should be aiming for a position where we can have 4000 cases a day,” he said, after simply being asked why he wouldn’t set a date, “then I don’t think Australians would agree with you”. As always, Scott Morrison is here to protect us – even if it means keeping people locked away indefinitely.

“In raising David’s case we are raising the historic and systemic failures of the Australian government to implement the royal commission findings, and to take and to adopt the recommendations from various UN bodies.”

Barrister Jennifer Robinson says Australia must be held to account for the 2015 death in custody of Indigenous man David Dungay, as the Dungay family takes the case to the United Nations.

“I asked 12 simple questions, the government has selectively chosen to answer five of them. My view is they should get on and answer the other seven.”

Yes, this is still going. Victorian shadow treasurer Louise Staley continues to press queries about Premier Daniel Andrews’ accident. Victoria Police chief commissioner Shane Patton confirmed to ABC radio this morning that there had been no reason for police to be involved.

It’s textbook ‘how not to run a war’
After 20 years of war, Australia gave three days’ notice before closing its embassy in Kabul. But the decision leaves hundreds of local staff vulnerable to retaliation by the Taliban.

The sum of a NSW government payment to an agricultural cooperative associated with federal minister Angus Taylor’s family, with a senior public servant directed to disguise it as a contract payment.

“The architect of the National Disability Insurance Scheme is disturbed that the federal government is still committed to an assessment model that has been slammed by the disability community.”

Inaugural NDIS chair Bruce Bonyhady calls for changes to independent assessments, saying the automated process “cannot possibly identify individual needs”.

The list

“These stories are all about small, individual lives lived intensely, joyfully, painfully, successfully, until intersecting planes of time catch up and everyone and everything dissolves into atoms, splitting and splitting again until they are nothing. Silbert has a power that the rarest old masters have: close up, you feel their breath breathing life, nothing less, across a rosy cheek. You hold your own breath in those suspended seconds.”

“If political impact is measured by how hard your opponents go after you, [Sally] McManus made one of the bigger entrances to public life. Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull christened her ‘Sally McManarchist’ in Question Time, and Christopher Pyne labelled her 7.30 comments ‘anarcho-Marxist claptrap’. Columnists solemnly declared the interview to be a disastrous start to her tenure. Labor leader Bill Shorten rushed to distance himself from her comments even as Greens leader Richard Di Natale declared, ‘Good on her.’”

“Thirty-two-year-old Zauner has built a career on grim internal excavations, and through talent, drive and ingenuity found herself with not just career sustainability – the baseline goal for many an indie musician – but a fan base who saw their own experiences reflected in her vignettes. Now she is a bona-fide star, with a billboard in Times Square and a book on the New York Times bestseller list.”

Rachel Withers

Rachel Withers is the contributing editor of The Monthly Today.



The Monthly Today

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce. Images via ABC News

Morrison’s mandate

Barnaby Joyce acknowledges that a net-zero target is cabinet’s call. But what exactly is their mandate?

Image of Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce in Question Time today. Image via ABC News

Rush hour

The Nationals have had far more than four hours to figure out their position on net zero

Composite image of NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet and Prime Minister Scott Morrison (images via ABC News)

Border farce

So much for the national plan

Image of Nationals deputy leader David Littleproud, leader Barnaby Joyce and leader in the Senate Bridget McKenzie, June 21, 2021. Image © Lukas Coch / AAP Image

Fear and showboating

The Nationals are worried about a net-zero backlash of their own making

From the front page

Image of ‘Bewilderment’

‘Bewilderment’ by Richard Powers

The Pulitzer winner’s open-hearted reworking of Flowers for Algernon, updated for modern times

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce. Images via ABC News

Morrison’s mandate

Barnaby Joyce acknowledges that a net-zero target is cabinet’s call. But what exactly is their mandate?

Image of ‘Scary Monsters’

‘Scary Monsters’ by Michelle de Kretser

Two satirical stories about fitting in, from the two-time Miles Franklin–winner

Image of Jeremy Strong as Kendall Roy in HBO’s Succession season 3. Photograph by David Russell/HBO

Ties that bind: ‘Succession’ season three

Jeremy Strong’s performance in the HBO drama’s third season is masterful