Wednesday, September 8, 2021

Today by Rachel Withers

Doses of nope
When it came to vaccine procurement, was Greg really in the hunt?

Image of Health Minister Greg Hunt. Image © Mick Tsikas / AAP Image

Health Minister Greg Hunt. Image © Mick Tsikas / AAP Image

Perceptions of the federal government’s vaccine procurement and rollout are set to go from fairly bad to absolutely terrible, amid confirmation that Australia really was at “the front of the queue” for vaccines, but that the health minister failed to step up. Nine and News have revealed that Pfizer approached Australia seeking a meeting with Greg Hunt, but was offered one with a health department first assistant secretary instead. Emails from June and July 2020 show the company was eager to meet with the minister “at the earliest opportunity”, urging the government to sign a deal ASAP so that “millions” of doses could be supplied in 2020. Hunt’s office didn’t meet with Pfizer until August 4 – with the government ultimately signing a deal for just 10 million doses in November, before later scrambling for more. The FOI-released documents seem to confirm what reports have been saying for months about the government’s botched negotiations with Pfizer – reports the government has repeatedly denied, implying there was nothing it could have done better. The reminder – that we could have had way more doses of Pfizer sooner – makes the government’s non-stop chirping of “doses of hope”, every time it secures some other country’s soon-to-expire-stock, all the more laughable, and the ongoing dispute over the redistribution of vaccines to NSW becomes all the more bleak. Australians wouldn’t have been fighting over who should get more of the desperately needed doses if the government – and specifically Greg Hunt – had bothered to do its job.

It’s not yet clear how damaging this news will be for Hunt, but much of it will come down to how it is played by the Opposition, which has already had some success in going after the Coalition on its vaccine procurement failures, especially since the impacts are being felt by most of the population. Labor has jumped on the reports with a non-stop stream of quips on Twitter, including from Kevin Rudd, whose smug “so there you have it folks!” seemed a subtle call back to his previous involvement in embarrassing Hunt. The health minister, keen to paint this revelation as a Labor beat-up, quickly released a statement hitting back at the “ALP claim” (despite the documents having been obtained and reported on by media outlets). “The ALP claim is false and has been refuted with facts on multiple occasions by multiple parties,” he wrote, adding that the “millions” of doses referenced in the email referred to Pfizer’s global capacity, not Australia’s offer – as if this in any way limits his culpability in failing to secure any of it with any urgency.

Hunt’s strategy here – the one he ran with through his PR war with Rudd, claiming that whatever he was being accused of had been denied by all parties – is unlikely to make much difference now that Australians are able to see the correspondence for themselves. And, unfortunately for Hunt, there’s no shortage of anger already out there regarding the rollout this week, especially in light of perceptions – true or not – that the federal government secretly gave additional Pfizer to NSW. (Politicians and data journalists continue fighting over this claim, with outlets from the Herald Sun to Guardian Australia offering up different interpretations of the opaque figures; but the impression of secrecy and favouritism has stuck.)

It also depends, of course, on how the prime minister chooses to treat his health minister, and whether he decides to cut him loose to save his own skin. That’s not an altogether unlikely proposition, with the PMO having previously appeared to leak against Hunt in a niche publication, apparently in order to cast the PM as the hero of the rollout. Such a move would be a cheap one: the entire federal government bears culpability for the vaccine rollout, for its failure to prioritise it, for its failure to vaccinate the vulnerable groups it was in charge of, and for the ill-conceived decision to declare, over and over, that it was “not a race”. These decisions have collectively sent more than half the population into avoidable lockdowns.

But it was Hunt, as is now abundantly clear, who failed to take up offers, despite being directly contacted by the maker of what has become our preferred vaccine. And it is Hunt who will ultimately have to pay the price for the botched rollout that has long demanded a scalp. Health ministers have resigned during this pandemic over far less, and Australians –  locked down, exasperated, struggling and dying – deserve far better.

“I think that Senator Cash, the attorney-general, needs to explain what her aim is in appointing someone to this position who’s got views like Ms Finlay.”

Shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus calls for an explanation over Lorraine Finlay’s appointment as Human Rights Commissioner, after Australian of the Year Grace Tame labelled it a “grave mistake”.

“If you don’t understand that deeply, then you’re not going to protect it as a million Australians have through their military service.”

Education Minister Alan Tudge continues to rail against the proposed new curriculum, especially its nuanced consideration of Anzac Day.

Just how stretched are our hospitals?
As Australia grapples with its biggest outbreak yet of COVID-19 the focus is shifting to hospitalisation figures and deaths. But even though COVID-19 wards are becoming busier, it isn’t easy to get a clear picture of just how bad things are in our hospital system.

The number of days since the government promised the nation a federal anti-corruption commission.

“The Morrison government is preparing for a pandemic election with legislation to allow more time and reasons to cast a pre-poll or postal vote.”

Another electoral bill is being prepared for the October and November sittings of parliament, but it stops short of a broader overhaul to allow the electoral commissioner to change the date of polling in response to an emergency, as recommended by the electoral matters committee.

The list

“After decades of hollowing out, the nation-state capacity of the Commonwealth has largely been reduced to two elements: financial and military. In more vernacular terms, all the government does is sign cheques (preferably oversized, novelty ones) and send in the military. In many cases, even these functions have been reduced to theatre.”

“It is rare that we can date, with precision, the moment when a species passes into oblivion. The last known thylacine died in Beaumaris Zoo, Hobart, on 7 September 1936. There was no fanfare, no marking of the final disappearance of the largest carnivorous marsupial known to the modern era. The thylacine, which had been trapped and taken to the zoo three years earlier, was locked out of its sleeping quarters and quickly succumbed to a combination of neglect and extreme weather. It was an inglorious end for a species little loved during its lifetime … Since 1936, there has not been a single confirmed sighting and it’s difficult to find a scientist who believes that thylacines are still out there. Case closed? Well, not quite.”

“Most Australians may not realise it, but their current car is quite likely the last fossil fuel-powered vehicle they will ever own. That’s the view of the New South Wales Environment minister, Matt Kean, and although it may sound like a big call, it’s pretty much a statistical inevitability. The average life of a car in Australia is almost 11 years, and 11 years from now we will be well on the other side of the biggest automotive revolution since the Model T rolled off Henry Ford’s new production line in 1913.” 

Rachel Withers

Rachel Withers is the contributing editor of The Monthly Today.



The Monthly Today

Nuclear fallout

The waves from Australia’s cancelled submarine contract keep building

Composite image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison (image via Facebook) and Industry Minister Christian Porter (image via Sky News).

The standard you walk past

Ministerial standards breach or no, there is something deeply wrong with the government’s principles

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison announcing the new AUKUS partnership alongside UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson and US President Joe Biden (not pictured). Image via ABC News

Whatever it takes

Scott Morrison says we will spend whatever we have to on defence. Why doesn’t the same apply to climate change?

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison and former finance minister Mathias Cormann, who is now secretary-general of the OECD. Image via Facebook

The world is watching

The OECD recommends that Australia take action on climate change. Is our government listening?

From the front page

Nuclear fallout

The waves from Australia’s cancelled submarine contract keep building

Image of Colson Whitehead's ‘Harlem Shuffle’

‘Harlem Shuffle’ by Colson Whitehead

The author of ‘The Underground Railroad’ offers a disappointingly straightforward neo-noir caper set in the early ’60s

Composite image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison (image via Facebook) and Industry Minister Christian Porter (image via Sky News).

The standard you walk past

Ministerial standards breach or no, there is something deeply wrong with the government’s principles

Image of Paul Kelly

Unfinished business

Every Paul Kelly song so far, from worst to best