Wednesday, April 7, 2021

Today by Rachel Withers

He said, EU said
Strap in for a game of semantics with Scott Morrison

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison speaking at a press conference today. Image via ABC News

Prime Minister Scott Morrison speaking at a press conference today. Image via ABC News

Prime Minister Scott Morrison this morning cried “semantics”, after the European Commission overnight denied the Australian government’s claims that the EU had blocked 3.1 million doses of AstraZeneca’s COVID-19 vaccine from being shipped to Australia, saying it had only blocked the previously reported 250,000-dose shipment. In a statement released this morning, the prime minister’s office accused Europe of “arguing semantics” about what it had formally blocked, as it had informally signalled it would block other applications to export vaccines from the region. Two hours later, Morrison fronted a press conference, supposedly in an attempt to calm the growing diplomatic storm, arguing that he hadn’t blamed the EU. “I want to stress that at no time yesterday did I make any comment about the actions of the European Union,” he said, “nor did I indicate any of the background reasons for the lack of supply that we have received from those contracted doses.” He went on: “I simply stated a fact: that 3.1 millon of the contracted vaccines that we had been relying upon in early January when we’d set out a series of targets did not turn up in Australia.” So why did the EU think his government had blamed them? And where is the vaccine stock?

The European Commission’s rejection came in response to a range of comments from the Australian government over the past few days. After last week’s attempt to blame the states blew up in the government’s face, members of Morrison’s team began trotting out the line that the EU had blocked supply, with 3.1 million doses not having arrived from Europe. An Australian government source told Reuters: “They’ve blocked 3.1 million shots so far.” In reality, they had blocked 250,000, and reportedly suggested that other orders would be rejected too.

Morrison is technically correct in saying that he did not make any comments “about the actions of the European Union” yesterday. At Tuesday’s press conference, Morrison simply said there had been a “supply problem”, with “over 3 million doses from overseas that never came”. He never mentioned the EU directly or used the word “blocked” – though his message was fairly clear. But other members of his government have been far less subtle. On Monday, Agriculture Minister David Littleproud – the man who last week blasted Queensland for having unused vaccines in storage – told Today that Australia was “3 million short by the EU”, adding that we had been “undercut” by the European Union. On ABC News Breakfast this morning, Trade Minister Dan Tehan – surely an important source on the matter – continued to use the word “blocked”, even after the European Commission had called out the claim. When offered the chance to admit there was no block on the 3.1 million doses, he said, “No, that’s not what you’re hearing from me … An application was put in and that application was blocked.” Treasurer Josh Frydenberg engaged in some linguistics of his own, telling Breakfast that “the fact that they’re not giving approval is effectively the same as blocking”.

If the EU did informally block all of Australia’s 3.1 million missing doses (and it appears they did), the European Commission certainly is engaging in some deceptive semantics. But so, it’s clear, is the prime minister. Much like with last week’s attack on the states, Morrison kept his hands clean, and did not make direct attacks on the EU himself. But there’s no doubt he wanted his new scapegoat known. Even this morning, as Morrison denied having blamed the EU, he carried on doing so – laying out everything the EU had done while insisting it would be “completely incorrect to suggest he had criticised them.

Semantics might also be Morrison’s justification for his government’s repeated claims, over months, that the vaccine rollout was not behind schedule; or for his suggestion in this morning’s presser that reports of bickering and blame-shifting with the states were just media beat-ups; or perhaps for the words of the man standing beside him, Department of Health Secretary Brendan Murphy, who said – with a straight face – that the rollout is going “well”. The PM might also like to use semantics to explain away comments from former Australia Post chief executive Christine Holgate, who yesterday spoke out in an explosive Senate inquiry submission, alleging she had been humiliated in parliament and unlawfully stood down. Holgate, Morrison told reporters in this morning’s presser, had “decided to leave Australia Post” before the review into the luxury watches she gifted senior executives was completed. “That’s just a matter of record,” he added gently, echoing his comments about Europe and “facts”.

In a clip posted to Twitter this morning, journalist Tegan George contrasted Morrison’s comments from this morning with those he made in parliament last October. “She’s been instructed to stand aside,” the PM shouted angrily in comments that were widely broadcast. “And if she doesn’t wish to do that, Mr Speaker, she can GO.” Holgate claimed yesterday that she was forced out, but does the PM screaming for you to quit really count? Let’s not get into semantics.

“The politics are now so toxic that the community is confused & losing trust. Trust got us through 2020. What’s needed is a cathartic re-set. No spin. The facts even if they’re unpalatable, should be on the table. NOT via News LTD. Then a new plan based on capacity to deliver.”

ABC health commentator Dr Norman Swan calls for a reset.

“Labor should declare Josh (women are dogs) Bornstein unfit to enter parliament.”

Journalist Peter van Onselen, a friend and defender of Christian Porter, thinks lawyer Josh Bornstein is unfit for office, after The Australian dug up an old tweet in which Bornstein likened a senior female unionist to a dog.

The plan to lock up more Indigenous children
In 2015 the Northern Territory government announced a Royal Commission into Youth Detention, but six years on almost every single young person in prison in the NT is Indigenous. Now, the NT government has announced new laws that could see even more young Indigenous people locked up.


The number of projects funded against departmental advice in a $200 million round of the Building Better Regions Fund in the lead-up to the 2019 election, following an intervention by Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack. 

“The Reserve Bank, its operations and its key policy objective of holding inflation between 2 and 3 per cent would be the focus of a review under a Labor government amid warnings the institution is being left behind by overseas central banks.”

Labor has joined calls for a review of the RBA and its policy objectives – something that hasn’t occurred in four decades.

The list

“I got on a thought-train, then, and rode it out past the stations of the sad men, the interchange named Robert Smith, the Thom Yorke branch line, the other Smith, Elliott, and Drake looming down at me from every billboard along the way. I know the whole damn network, as do these women: the most palpable influence on Bridger’s much-lauded 2020 album, Punisher, is Elliott Smith … But there are stops on the network where no one wants to disembark: the stations where if you hang around for long you get called crazy. There goes Janis Joplin, Whitney Houston, Amy Winehouse, Britney Spears, Courtney Love, Sinéad O’Connor, Azealia Banks, and on and on, rushing past the window. The stations of the sad women, who are known as madwomen.”

“Everywhere the camera turns in the remarkable Romanian documentary Collective (in cinemas April 8), something is in flames. It begins with the noise-proofing material in the Bucharest nightclub Colectiv, which catches alight during a band’s performance and kills numerous patrons, but the ensuing political firestorm soon encompasses the flagrant denials of culpability by a government forced to resign, and finally it reaches the venal underpinnings of a ruling system predicated on corruption. Quietly staggering in scene after scene, Alexander Nanau’s film is not only a jarring 21st century history of official disdain, profit’s insatiable hunger and the media’s response, but also a stark warning to any democratic society.”

“The COVID-19 lockdowns disproportionately affected renters. These people are more likely to be younger, on lower incomes, in insecure work or on temporary visas. Towards the end of last year, Better Renting estimated that up to 970,000 renters were experiencing rental stress and could face eviction. The chief executive of Tenants Victoria, Jennifer Beveridge, has warned of a ‘flood of evictions’ in coming months.”

Rachel Withers

Rachel Withers is the contributing editor of The Monthly Today.



The Monthly Today

27 reasons to wonder

Another “win” for Porter in the case that he desperately didn’t want made public

Image of Scott Morrison in a Santa hat

The ghost of Christmas past

Morrison’s attempts at good tidings are little comfort to those who might be in lockdown until the end of the year

Pay as you go

With Morrison, help is gradual and insufficient

Composite image of Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews and NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian. Images via ABC News

A tale of two lockdowns

As some states lift restrictions, the NSW premier is keen to reject comparisons with Victoria

From the front page

27 reasons to wonder

Another “win” for Porter in the case that he desperately didn’t want made public

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Jenny Morrison laying a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknown Australian Soldier during the Anzac Day commemorative service on April 25, 2020. Image © Alex Ellinghausen / AAP Image/ Sydney Morning Herald Pool

A rallying crime

For a country that loves invoking the virtues of wartime sacrifice, why have our leaders failed to appeal to the greater good during the pandemic?

Photo of installation view of the exhibition Camille Henrot: Is Today Tomorrow at NGV International. Photo © Tom Ross

Simultaneous persuasions: ‘Camille Henrot: Is Today Tomorrow’

Radical difference and radical proximity are hallmarks of the French-born artist’s NGV exhibition

Cover image of The Airways

Body and soul: ‘The Airways’

Fusing elements of crime fiction and ghost stories, Jennifer Mills’ latest novel is an interrogation of gender, power and consent