The Politics    Monday, July 5, 2021

Morrison the menace?

By Rachel Withers

Image of former Liberal MP Julia Banks. Image via Facebook

Former Liberal MP Julia Banks. Image via Facebook

Why are the allegations the PM engaged in “controlling” behaviour against a former MP not bigger news?

Over the weekend, a well-respected former Coalition MP accused the prime minister of “menacing, controlling” behaviour, of bullying and backgrounding against her, and making a calculated effort to get her out of parliament. Why isn’t this major news? Former Chisholm MP Julia Banks – who in August 2018, following the spill that installed Scott Morrison as leader, announced that she would not be standing at the next election, before moving to the crossbench and calling out the Liberal Party’s toxic culture as she went – has revealed further details of what went on during that time in an excerpt from her new book, published in the Nine weekend papers. Much of the limited media attention has so far focused, understandably, on her allegation that an unnamed Coalition MP slid his hand up her thigh during drinks at Parliament House, with questions asked about that incident. But what of the fact that the prime minister tried to silence Banks, with his vicious treatment partly behind her decision to quit the party? Those allegations will be foregrounded again tonight, when Banks appears on 7.30, and perhaps then they will get the increased attention they rightfully deserve. But when will the nation start asking serious questions about the man who leads this country?

In her extract, and in the preview for her upcoming interview with 7.30, Banks goes further than she has previously in describing Morrison’s behaviour towards her in the days and weeks following the spill, describing him as a “constant, menacing, background wallpaper” who used his “intermediaries” to do his bidding. As well as elaborating on the inappropriate advances so often faced by women in politics, Banks lays out exactly what the new PM did to her after he took the reins from Malcolm Turnbull, whom she publicly supported. When Banks decided not to re-contest the election, Morrison personally pressured her not to announce her decision so close to the spill, to avoid making his government look bad. When she agreed to give him the 24 hours he asked for before making her announcement, the prime minister’s office allegedly backgrounded against her, setting the narrative that she was “weak” and “over-emotional”, while Morrison himself showed concern for “Julia” and her welfare in his public-facing press conferences, implying that she was struggling with the strain of it all. (This is a familiar playbook for the PM, Banks notes, comparing her situation to that of Brittany Higgins and Christine Holgate.) Banks says she was then portrayed in the media in a “stereotypical sexist narrative … everything from emotionally weak and precious to an aggressive, attention-seeking bully bitch”. Morrison’s marketing skills appear to have abandoned him lately, but if Banks’s claims are to be believed, they were operating at full capacity when he tried to exert influence over her. He then reportedly tried to pressure her out of parliament, offering her paired leave or the chance to go to New York as the UN delegate, at taxpayer expense, in what Banks saw as further efforts to silence her.

So why haven’t Banks’s claims about the character of our prime minister received greater attention? There is of course the current COVID-19 crisis, and this isn’t the first piece of damning news about the federal government, and specifically the prime minister, that hasn’t been able to get the airtime it deserves because of the pandemic. The car park rorts saga – “sports rorts on steroids” – and Morrison’s UK family history jaunt both struggled to take precedence over major lockdowns and vaccine debacles. There is also the fact that the reports about Morrison’s behaviour have been overshadowed by Banks’s claims of sexual harassment against an anonymous MP, which are utterly galling. Could it also be that Morrison’s apparent efforts to portray her as either “a weak petal” or a “Turnbull puppet” out for revenge against him have worked too well, despite the fact that Banks has never come off as anything other than calm and composed about her experiences?

Banks was an early whistleblower when it came to the culture within the Coalition, and many of her previous claims about parliament’s toxic “boys’ club” environment were vindicated when Brittany Higgins came forward in February, setting off an avalanche of other stories. Banks’s latest claims about the prime minister’s behaviour, if true, paint a portrait of a malicious bully, willing to do anything to maintain his power, including backgrounding, pressuring, lying and manipulating in order to make a woman look weak. (In a statement to the ABC, a spokesperson for the PM said he had “several conversations with her to understand what she was going through” but “absolutely rejects claims about the nature of those conversations”.) Throughout the sexism crisis that engulfed politics earlier this year, Morrison – with his wholesome Christian and “daggy dad” persona – was never seen as one of the abusers or harassers himself, claiming to be blindsided and “devastated” by reports of what women go through. Even in the aftermath of the spill that made him PM, Morrison was eager to portray himself as one of the good guys, a well-meaning individual who rose to the top through luck and talent, not one of the menaces making people cry. Banks’s latest allegations should put a stop to that. The sexism, in case anyone was left in any doubt, stems from the top.

“Breakdowns of fundamental standards of governance don’t come much bigger than the Morrison government’s medley of pandemic policy and performance failures on aged care, quarantine and vaccination. For these reasons, Health Minister Greg Hunt should resign, or else Morrison should dismiss him now.”

Former PM Kevin Rudd joins the many voices trying to get the federal government to take one iota of responsibility.

“The Australian people had their chance and voted the government back in at the last election, and we’re determined to get on and deliver those election promises that we made in relation to local infrastructure.”

Finance Minister Simon Birmingham says the Coalition’s pork-barrelling of the commuter car park fund was okay because it won the election, and refuses to rule out similar actions in the future.

The judgement that changed climate law in Australia
In a recent landmark judgement, the Federal Court has found that the government owes children a duty of care in preventing harm from the impacts of climate change. The case, which centred around the proposed expansion of a NSW coalmine, could have far-reaching legal implications in Australia.


The number of male contenders in the five-way LNP preselection race to replace disgraced MP Andrew Laming at the next election. The sole man, Henry Pike, won despite being investigated over fat-shaming and sexist text messages.

“Barnaby Joyce says he is in favour of offering a path to citizenship for workers who come from Asia to the regions on the newly announced agriculture visa, in what could be a contentious shake-up of the migration program.”

The deputy prime minister says Asian workers who come to Australia on a new agriculture visa – being negotiated to make up for the shortfall in UK migrant workers – should be allowed to apply for citizenship if they have “the prospect of being a good citizen”.

The list

“Kafkaesque is an adjective often used offhandedly to describe frustrating encounters with bureaucracy. But there is no word more apt to describe Tadese’s situation. He was stuck in a surreal world in which all of his plans, all sense of control, had fallen to pieces. He found himself pitted against a system that insisted there was some essential and inescapable part of his identity that was to blame for his own predicament. He didn’t want to give up, but he also felt like he didn’t stand a chance.”

“On a good night, when I’m walking because I want to (not because I’m broke), it feels as though the city is falling in step with me, finally, and all the cars, the trees, the streetlights assume a quiet order as I pass by. There is no work now, no errands, nothing to buy, no one to meet. In motion, in the in-between, there’s pause to let my thoughts run over the night, the times, my life. We walk at the pace of our thoughts, suggests Rebecca Solnit, and my legs paraphrase.”

“In Monday’s tense national cabinet meeting, held as nearly half the country went into lockdown due to the spread of the Delta strain of COVID-19, the country’s chief health officers urged Scott Morrison to dump its commitment to AstraZeneca. The Saturday Paper has spoken to several people with direct knowledge of how the emergency meeting late on Monday unfolded. There was a sense of panic and frustration from the prime minister, who also grilled the Australian Health Protection Principal Committee (AHPPC), the advisory body for chief health and medical officers, about making vaccines mandatory for aged-care workers.”

Rachel Withers

Rachel Withers is the contributing editor of The Politics.


The Politics

Image of Anthony Albanese

Whither progress?

In a threatening climate, the first full year of the Albanese government has been defined by caution and incrementalism

6 News Australia interviews Gen Z Party founder Thomas Rex Dolan. Image via X.

Grift of the gab

Strange things are happening to our political system, and it’s time the major parties started paying attention

Voting results displayed on two large screens at the UN General Assembly’s tenth emergency special session

Ceaseless politics

The Albanese government calls for a ceasefire, and the Coalition goes on the attack

Image of Chris Bowen speaking at COP28

Not phased

What good are nice words about phasing out fossil fuels when Australia continues to expand and export?

From the front page

Kim Williams seen through window with arms half-raised

The interesting Mr Williams

At a time when the ABC faces more pressure than ever before, is its new chair the right person for the job?

Exterior of the Department of Treasury, Canberra

Tax to grind

Tax reform should not be centred on what we want, but on who we want to be

Rehearsal for the ABC TV show ‘Cooking with Wine’, March 13, 1956

Whose ABC?

Amid questions of relevance and culture war hostilities, the ABC’s charter clearly makes the case for a government-funded national broadcaster

Tony McNamara in New York City, January 2024

Pure things: Tony McNamara

How the Australian screenwriter of ‘Poor Things’, who cut his teeth on shows such as ‘The Secret Life of Us’, earnt his second Oscar nomination