Wednesday, March 3, 2021

Today by Rachel Withers

Porter speaks
The attorney-general denies the allegations, but admits he can’t disprove them

Image of Attorney-General Christian Porter. Image via ABC News

Attorney-General Christian Porter. Image via ABC News

Attorney-General Christian Porter has come forward as the government minister accused of raping a 16-year-old in 1988, denying the allegations and refusing to step down. Porter said that “nothing in the allegations that have been printed ever happened”, that he had never seen the accuser’s statement and that the allegations had never been put to him for a response. Porter admitted having spoken to PM Scott Morrison about the allegations last week, but, remarkably, said he had not been given a copy of the letter detailing the allegations. The emotional attorney-general admitted he knew the woman in question for a short time in the late ’80s but insisted that they had never slept together. Porter said he would be taking a short period of leave to assess and improve his mental health, telling the press conference that he wasn’t sure if he was okay. The only sign of anger came during questioning, when it was pointed out to him that he could not disprove the allegation. “Of course I can’t,” he said.

Porter, who can never be cleared or found guilty of the rape, spoke at length about the importance of the rule of law, raising fears over what it would mean for “every child we raise” if people’s lives could be destroyed by accusations alone (never mind what it means for the woman whose life may or may not have been destroyed by a traumatic incident). Porter claimed there would be a dangerous new standard set if he were to resign, insisting that he was protecting the rule of law by not stepping down. Porter also relied on previous allegations against former Labor leader Bill Shorten, as conservatives have done all week, noting that he now understood what it was like for Shorten to have to do the “difficult thing” in waiting until the police investigation had come to an end before speaking out. The two cases are not the same, as much as attempts were made to refloat the Shorten allegations late last week, with Shorten’s accuser still alive and able to give her account.

Porter, who was previously investigated by Four Corners over his behaviour and attitudes towards women, has been hounded by long-running rumours of sexism and inappropriate behaviour, including making unwanted advances to women while in federal office and public drunkenness, as well as allegations from his university days and his time as a Crown prosecutor in Western Australia. In the extensive questioning in today’s press conference, Porter was asked if he could be the subject of similar allegations to the one at hand or if he had ever asked someone to sign a non-disclosure agreement, both of which he rejected. He said he didn’t remember much of the debating championship week in question (other than “bowls of prawns”), but said he would surely have remembered a disturbing incident like the one being alleged in a trove of diary entries and statements.

The Morrison government reportedly hopes this afternoon’s statement will mark the “end of the matter”, and Porter clearly wants that to be so, but it’s almost certainly not. Four Corners journalist Louise Milligan, who broke the story of the letter from the deceased woman’s friends, hinted on Twitter late last night that she has more, saying that NSW Police was “very interested to know if I knew of other complainants”. “Not in your jurisdiction,” she replied. Porter will want to tread carefully here, and not make any claims that can be easily disproved by an award-winning investigative reporter on a mission.

In unfortunate timing for Porter and the government, sexual abuse survivor and Australian of the Year Grace Tame earlier today addressed the National Press Club, in a brave and eloquent speech that received a standing ovation and left many in the room close to tears. Tame once again recounted her story of being groomed and abused by her teacher as a teen, but she also took the opportunity to warn against commodifying victims’ pain, reminding journalists that while “listening to survivors is one thing, expecting people to relive their trauma on your terms, without our consent, without prior warning, is another.” Tame said that abuse of power and cover-up culture was “not unique to parliament” but was rife in Australian society at large.

While journalists were asked to avoid mentioning specifics of the recent allegations dominating headlines, many questions put to Tame still referred to them obliquely, along with effusive praise for Tame herself. The Australian of the Year, who had recently been honoured by the prime minister, was asked what she thought of his recent “as a father” comments. “It shouldn’t take having children to have a conscience,” she said. “And, actually, on top of that, having children doesn’t guarantee a conscience,” she added, to a round of applause. She said the past few weeks had made her hopeful, saying that “people finding the courage to speak out” was “empowering”, but that she has not been surprised by some of the unhelpful dialogue. Barrister Kathleen Foley – who appeared on Four Corners’ “Canberra bubble” episode, calling Porter “deeply sexist” and a “misogynist” based on her time at university with him – also joined the conversation today, writing in the AFR that Morrison’s response to the allegations had been “nothing short of insulting”, suggesting he “take a leaf out of Tame’s book, out of Brittany Higgins’ book, and end his silence”.

Tame noted that a lot of resources were being put into responding to child sexual abuse, rather than preventing it. One might also note that irony of there being so much attention paid to the issue of child abuse by this government, which has spent the past five days refusing to address or look into allegations of a rape of a 16-year-old by someone within its own ranks. The government further highlighted this dichotomy today, with Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton helping launch the AFP’s new anti-child abuse initiative, appealing to the community for help in identifying victims of online sexual abuse.

The Australian was enthusiastic in reporting the new initiative this morning (as it is with any child sex abuse-preventing initiative), but it too has become increasingly keen to shut down conversation about one very specific instance of sexual abuse. The Murdoch media, despite kicking off the conversation that brought about the Porter allegations with its reporting on Brittany Higgins’s rape allegation, has now gone hard in the attorney-general’s defence, dedicating its opinion pages to commentary on why Porter should be allowed to deny this and move on. National editor Dennis Shanahan argued that the precedent set by the Bill Shorten allegations, where charges were also not laid due to insufficient evidence, meant that the Coalition minister needed to be allowed to move on too – ignoring the very different circumstances here – while Paul Kelly insists that a rape trial by media is a threat to justice. “So far, only one side of this story is being propagated, based on documents prepared by the victim and her supporters,” wrote Kelly. 

Now that Porter has come forward to deny the allegations, both sides of the story have been “propagated”, as Kelly put it. But in this case of “she said, he said” (as Dutton would put it), only one person is able to address the contested allegations directly, because “she” can no longer say anything. The deceased accuser, who killed herself last year, has now had her story refuted, but cannot refute his in return, and can speak only through letters and friends. With Porter’s denial getting such a public hearing, it’s more important than ever that we also hear what she – and they – has to say.

National Sexual Assault, Domestic and Family Violence Counselling Service 1800 737 732

“I am ultimately accountable.”

Rio Tinto chairman Simon Thompson says the words we don’t hear nearly enough, as he announces he will step down within the next year over the blasting of the Juukan Gorge caves.

“In his view, being aware of the four As – young, attractive people, noting the entire class fell into this risk factor; alcohol; after midnight; and alone – enabled the group to recognise and mitigate the threat posed by abusive or predatory individuals.”

The Australian Defence Force defends General Angus Campbell, after he told new recruits at the ADF Academy to avoid being “prey” to predators.

The sexual assault crisis that rocked Australia
A cabinet minister in the federal government has been accused of rape, but he hasn’t been publicly identified and the prime minister has so far refused to initiate an inquiry into the allegations. Today, Karen Middleton on the sexual assault crisis that has rocked the country.

The amount by which the economy expanded in the December quarter, beating expectations.

“Google claims that to pull harmful content off the internet within a day under proposed new laws could lead to technology companies inadvertently shutting down entire websites.”


Google has used a parliamentary inquiry to raise concerns about the government’s proposed online safety bill.

The list

“We have now entered the second decade of constitutional recognition. Six processes and nine reports in 10 years. And this ninth report seeks to decouple the first decade of work, which involved contributions from many Australians from all walks of life, from its considerations. The Uluru dialogues, which culminated in the First Nations National Constitutional Convention, were unanimous that there was no single existing entity or organisation that represented their voice. This has been ignored as bureaucrats and their cheerleaders have sought to neutralise the Uluru process by insisting that, despite what the dialogues said about powerlessness and voicelessness, there were, to the contrary, plenty of representative mechanisms that already exist at a state, territory and local level. Voila!”

“Rape victims seek justice in many ways, only one of which is the conviction and sentencing of their perpetrator. But that’s really the only kind of justice on offer in Australia. Restorative justice advocates say it isn’t enough for many survivors, as many as 99 per cent of whom never even achieve it anyway. With its focus on survivors’ needs (to recover and heal, to have their experience acknowledged – including by the perpetrator – and validated), restorative justice offers what criminal justice doesn’t, and can’t.”

“A market is not meant to be a passive experience, which means the best defence is a strong pretence: keep your phone in your pocket, don’t display a camera and feign an important but distant destination. Even as you shut out one part of the medina, more rushes in. The scent of freshly baked bread, fruit, spices and horse urine compete for space in the sensory nervous system with the taste of mint tea and the dry heat of the day. All around, merchants and shoppers dodge buzzing motorbikes that wend their way between stalls and down narrow paths made concave with almost a millennia of use.”

Rachel Withers

Rachel Withers is the contributing editor of The Monthly Today.



The Monthly Today

Strange bedfellows

The battlelines are blurring as Melbourne’s lockdown protests heat up

Nuclear fallout

The waves from Australia’s cancelled submarine contract keep building

Composite image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison (image via Facebook) and Industry Minister Christian Porter (image via Sky News).

The standard you walk past

Ministerial standards breach or no, there is something deeply wrong with the government’s principles

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison announcing the new AUKUS partnership alongside UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson and US President Joe Biden (not pictured). Image via ABC News

Whatever it takes

Scott Morrison says we will spend whatever we have to on defence. Why doesn’t the same apply to climate change?

From the front page

Strange bedfellows

The battlelines are blurring as Melbourne’s lockdown protests heat up

Black Summer at Currowan

A community’s experience of Australia’s worst bushfires

Image of Charif Majdalani’s ‘Beirut 2020’

‘Beirut 2020’ by Charif Majdalani

The Lebanese writer’s elegiac journal captures the city’s devastating port explosion

Nuclear fallout

The waves from Australia’s cancelled submarine contract keep building