Wednesday, February 19, 2020

Today by Paddy Manning

Not-so-hard Labor
Albanese has every reason to keep doing what he’s doing

Source: Twitter

There is disappointment in certain quarters that Labor leader Anthony Albanese is playing both sides on the hard issues like climate change, refusing to be pinned down. At worst, Albanese gets castigated from the right and left. The Australian yesterday ran an almost-gotcha piece on an apparent shift in Albanese’s language on coal – a failure to love the stuff sufficiently – while elsewhere there is exasperation at the antics of the pro-coal Otis Group at a time when the nation is still reeling from “black summer”. Like Howard versus Beazley, Prime Minister Scott Morrison has certainly made this line of attack a feature of his criticism of Albanese in parliament – saying he “wants to have it each way on every bet”. But the truth is, it’s working. A senior Labor operative made the point recently that last year Albanese would never have dreamed he and the ALP would be ahead in the polls at this point in the electoral cycle. Why would Labor want its internal policy debates to distract from a government careering from crisis to crisis – from Hawaii to sports rorts to coronavirus to robodebt?

Albanese has made the point repeatedly that it’s the position come election time that matters, not what’s happening today. Instead of rushing to fixed decisions, what seems to be happening in Labor is something a little more tactical, and perhaps even thoughtful. Some digging back into Labor history is going on. Two key economic speeches today illustrate the point.

In the first, an address at the Queensland Media Club, Albanese outlines a “positive ageing strategy”, reaffirming Labor’s support for a gradual increase in superannuation to 12 per cent, against opposition from some in the Coalition, the Grattan Institute and ACOSS. Albanese points out that it was the Labor government of Andrew Fisher – “a great Queenslander” – that introduced the old-age pension in 1908, “ensuring for the first time that working Australians could retire with dignity. We were one of the first nations in the world to do it.” Albanese hits a few aspirational notes – no mention of franking credits – and slips in a few digs at the cuts to pensions under then treasurer Morrison from 2015, and dragging the chain on deeming rates. He cites a Deloitte study that found a 3 per cent increase in workforce participation by over 55s would give the economy a $33 billion boost. Plenty of upside there.

In a second speech, Andrew Leigh reaches back to the late Victorian premier John Cain, who took Labor to power in 1982, ending 30 years of Liberal rule. If Victoria is the country’s most progressive state now, it was not always so, and it started with Cain. Labor has won 71 per cent of Victorian state elections since 1982, but governed only half that time federally. Reflecting on last year’s defeat, Leigh cites Andrew Charlton’s analysis that Labor’s primary vote fell on average by 1.3 per cent over the prior 10 elections. In 2019, it fell by 1.4 per cent. “That’s a structural trend, which goes beyond personalities and unexpected events,” says Leigh. “Following our election loss, there were more explanations for why we lost than we had policies. What struck me was the number of people who contended that we should discard ideas based on nothing more than politics. As a friend of mine put it, it was akin to saying, ‘the kids didn’t like their Christmas present – let’s buy them something different next year’.” This reads like a not-so-veiled defence of the rigorous platform taken to the last election – a plea not to throw the baby out with the bathwater.

Leigh pulls no punches, contrasting the Cain government’s “austere integrity” and commitment to sound policy with today’s “show ponies and charlatans” (not sure which party he’s referring to there). Then Leigh gets stuck into policy, arguing that Australia’s economy has slipped into a “deep structural malaise” since the Coalition was elected, partly due to declining productivity and partly due to a failure of Australian companies to innovate or invest. “It’s not just that companies aren’t investing simply in technology,” says Leigh, “they’re not investing in anything at all.” There’s been “a motza of mergers, but a scarcity of start-ups”. The result? Declining complexity of the Australian economy. And record wage stagnation – continuing in the latest official figures today. The answer? Leigh reaches back to Cain who “taught progressives that idealism and discipline were essential to bringing about change. His government was productive and innovative – characteristics that are essential not only to the Australian economy, but to any reforming Labor government.” 

Morrison says today’s Opposition is nothing like the Labor of Hawke and Keating, and he might be right. But if Labor goes back to its roots and takes the time to get its platform right, it could be.

“Sure, people have all sorts of views about Julian Assange. But when push comes to shove none of that is relevant. The substantive matter is that Julian Assange publicised US misconduct and presented hard evidence of their war crimes … At the end of the day no one should be punished for doing the right thing.”

Independent MP Andrew Wilkie, writing on the “alarming experience” of visiting WikiLeaks co-founder Julian Assange in London’s maximum-security Belmarsh Prison.

“People make mistakes. [This] does show there have been some significant issues across payroll systems across the market.”

Wesfarmers chief executive Rob Scott, on new revelations that Target staff have been underpaid by $9 million, while another $15 million remediation is outstanding in its industrial and safety division.

Suing over Howard’s camps
More than 60 former asylum seekers are seeking compensation for the psychological trauma they endured in Australia’s notorious Baxter detention centre. Now the lead case has stalled in the court system, delaying a decision. Rick Morton on the legacy of John Howard’s desert camps.


The number of people who ended their lives under Victoria’s voluntary assisted dying laws between June and December last year, which is higher than the dozen or so expected.

“The Morrison government will conduct an open competitive procurement process to secure a provider to deliver Australia’s sexual assault, domestic and family violence counselling service to meet increasing demand and provide the highest quality support … Demand for 1800RESPECT has grown rapidly since it started operating in 2010 when it was estimated the service would receive 20,000 calls each year. During the 2018–19 financial year 1800RESPECT responded to more than 163,000 phone and online contacts – a 66 per cent increase from the previous year.”

Social Services Minister Anne Ruston puts the 1800 RESPECT hotline to tender after a review found Medibank Health Solutions, the private provider that has run the call centre for the last decade, posed “financial risks” for the government.

The list

“Sitting in a studio some distance from the action, David Koch and Samantha Armytage brought the awkward, almost studied vacuity of breakfast TV to what might have been conversations of depth and pathos. You’re touring now? they ask k.d. lang. No, she’d flown in especially for this from Alberta, where she’d been spending time with her mother. Was the mateship significant? they ask firefighters. They’d only just met each other when they were sent out to battle blazes.”

“A $100 million environmental grants program, created ahead of last year’s federal election, had no eligibility guidelines and was open only to 25 specified projects that had already been chosen and announced as campaign promises – most of which were in seats held or targeted by the Coalition. There was no transparent selection process for the Environment Restoration Fund.” 

“In what sounds like artistic masochism, Castellucci has said he knows he has found what he wants when he feels ‘crushed by a theme’ and has his trust in theatre challenged. Requiem ‘slaps us in the face and forces us to face “the end”,’ he says now, with deliberately ambiguous phrasing: the end might also herald a new beginning.”

Paddy Manning

Paddy Manning is contributing editor (politics) at The Monthly and has worked for the ABC, Fairfax, Crikey and The Australian. He is the author of Inside the Greens and the unauthorised biography of Malcolm Turnbull, Born To Rule?


The Monthly Today

Pressed pause

Today’s COVID-19 modelling leaves Australia locked down for Easter

Oversight plight?

On balance, the parliament should sit through the pandemic response


All in this together, or in danger of turning on each other?

Snap back

The PM thinks the economy will rebound, but that’s not likely

From the front page

Illustration by Jeff Fisher

Slow work

Neighbours and friends rebuilding communities after the bushfires

Pressed pause

Today’s COVID-19 modelling leaves Australia locked down for Easter

Image of Max von Sydow in The Exorcist

Knight to rook 3

Remembering Max von Sydow, the greatest actor of his generation

Illustration by Jeff Fisher

Whitefella visits Kurnell

A Botany Bay ferry would restore Cook’s landing site as a ‘meeting place’