The Politics    Monday, May 11, 2020


By Paddy Manning


Mitchell Library, State Library of New South Wales and courtesy SEARCH Foundation

The green bans proved jobs-vs-environment is a sham

Heartfelt tributes are pouring in for legendary Australian communist, trade unionist and environmentalist Jack Mundey, who died on Sunday, aged 90. Twitter has seen statements from the ACTU and Australian Conservation Foundation, a string of Labor heavyweights including former Labor leader Bill Shorten, Greens leader Adam Bandt and many others. As leader of the NSW Builders Laborers Federation in the early 1970s, Mundey and his fellow “BLs” Bob Pringle and Joe Owens had a truly global impact. They launched the green bans movement, which stopped bulldozers from clearing remnant scrub on Sydney Harbour at Hunters Hill, then known as Kellys Bush, in 1971. It was the first time a union anywhere had stopped work on a project for environmental reasons – well outside normal pay and conditions – and the green bans unionists went on to save much of Sydney’s built heritage in The Rocks and Woolloomooloo, and places like Centennial Park, holding up developments worth billions in the name of environmental amenity or social justice. It also embraced causes from gay rights to public housing. Peace and anti-nuclear activist Petra Kelly came to Sydney in the late 1970s and, inspired by Mundey, went home and formed the German Greens, which in turn inspired the formation of Green parties around the world.

But the significance of the green bans – a term coined by Mundey in a 1973 interview – wasn’t just that they saved a few precious bits of Sydney during the early 1970s property boom. (It should be noted that even most property developers today are glad Mundey won those fights.) The green bans recognised that the environment and heritage mattered to working people, that gay rights mattered to working people (hence the first pink ban, as the ACTU’s Sally McManus acknowledged today), that public housing mattered to working people. And the green bans could not have happened without the earlier black bans, in which the radical BLs stood up and stopped dangerous work practices like “riding the hook” in the very early days of high-rise construction, and insisting labourers should not die at work. And the green bans unionists were not about self-glorification or entrenching themselves in the hierarchy. They believed in grassroots democracy, with everything decided on site by the unionists themselves in stop-work meetings that would often drag on for hours – as long as it took, with many labourers from multicultural backgrounds. They also believed in limited tenure; Jack Mundey himself went back on the tools after his first stint as state secretary. 

In short, Mundey and his fellow unionists saw at the outset that the jobs-versus-environment debate is a sham construct. Workers can have both, if they only insist on it. Consider how radical the green bans seem now, when the CFMEU (the successor to the Builders Laborers Federation) colluded with the far right against Stop Adani protesters at the last federal election, and national president Tony Maher tells Crikey [$] his union will never oppose a new coalmine that creates jobs. Yet new coal projects will literally make the planet uninhabitable for kids, not just those of the inner-city greenies, but the kids of regional coalminers as well – a much more serious threat than anything the BLF stared down 50 years ago. The CFMEU could, if it wished, stop the Adani project dead tomorrow (and with coal prices plummeting and projects being shelved, many coal companies would thank them). Unions across the world round could, if they wished, stop new fossil fuels forever. 

When I interviewed Mundey for my recent history of the Greens in Australia, he criticised the union movement for failing to move with the times: “The union movement now could be a real, important instrument in the whole ecological struggle, because the whole question of global warming, the whole question of the environment, is on the agenda forever more.” Could a green ban be slapped on the Adani mine, I asked Jack. “First of all, it’s convincing the workers themselves. I think there is a need for that sort of action to take place. And if workers could be motivated along those lines, I could see there’d be a great benefit to the whole workers’ movement.” 

As writer Jeff Sparrow pointed out today, former ACTU president Bob Hawke saw Mundey as a “menace” – the ’70s green bans represented exactly the kind of industrial unrest which, as PM, he stopped using the accord and union amalgamations. In his fifth vision speech today, Labor leader Anthony Albanese soft-pedalled on the policies that the Opposition would take to the next election, but has signalled that the party will dump ambitious policies on franking credits or negative gearing, for example. Last week, he was taking flak for committing to an entirely uncontroversial zero emissions by 2050 emissions target. Let’s hope that in the spirit of Jack Mundey – a true giant of the Australian labour movement – the ALP does not go to water on everything. 

“Good to see the Canberra press gallery is back to politics as usual with parliament coming back.”

Prime Minister Scott Morrison – after flatly denying he misled parliament over the controversial sports grants program, despite the auditor advising on Friday that his office intervened – gets it right for the wrong reasons.

“Can I say Mr Barilaro is an outstanding advocate for the bush. Especially during the drought, especially during bushfires, and he has my full support.”

NSW premier Gladys Berejiklian stands by deputy premier and state Nationals leader John Barilaro after last week’s public brawling over the Coalition’s byelection campaign in Eden-Monaro.

Inside the Newmarch cluster
An aged-care facility in NSW is the site of one of Australia’s biggest clusters of COVID-19. Now, with 16 dead, the centre’s owners have been threatened with sanctions and the loss of their licence. Today, Rick Morton on what went wrong at Newmarch House.

The likely minimum underspend on the $130 billion JobKeeper wage-subsidy program, which is supporting a million fewer employees than expected.

“Bushfire-affected communities will share in $448.5 million from the Australian Government to support the delivery of local economic recovery plans and projects. Projects could range from initiatives that promote economic activity and support community wellbeing, projects that focus on the landscape and water, replacing produce and stock, or building future resilience …  Local councils will work with their regional bushfire recovery coordinators and state governments to provide the National Bushfire Recovery Agency with a list of priority projects as soon as possible.”

An outline of the Regional Bushfire Recovery and Development Program, part of $650 million in new funding announced by the prime minister.

The list

“If you find yourself sleeping on the floor of a shed, it’s easy to believe you’re in the early stages of greatness, rather than just going badly. As a society, we are enamoured with the Cinderella story. I lay on the grease-stained carpet, as the wind whipped in and under the door, waiting for the ol’ upswing in fortunes, thinking, Any moment now! Then, surprisingly, improbably, things got slightly worse.”

“This exercise in self-indulgent bickering is obviously seen as a free kick for Labor and its leader, Anthony Albanese, who needs a highly marginal byelection at a time of Morrison’s sudden rise in popularity like he needs a positive COVID test. However, it may make things harder for the Opposition. On paper, history shows a Coalition win would be most unlikely, but it would be regarded as another of Morison’s miracles if he can pull it off – and thus a disaster for Albanese, who has everything to lose.”

“Sydney Festival director Wesley Enoch says Carriageworks ‘needs more resources to play its role in the arts ecology … What we need is a strong advocate for the arts. This is not a time to be playing politics back and forward; we’re talking about the livelihoods of thousands of people in the arts and creative industries.’”

Paddy Manning

Paddy Manning is contributing editor at The Monthly and the author of Inside the Greens and Body Count.

The Politics

Image of Anthony Albanese

Whither progress?

In a threatening climate, the first full year of the Albanese government has been defined by caution and incrementalism

6 News Australia interviews Gen Z Party founder Thomas Rex Dolan. Image via X.

Grift of the gab

Strange things are happening to our political system, and it’s time the major parties started paying attention

Voting results displayed on two large screens at the UN General Assembly’s tenth emergency special session

Ceaseless politics

The Albanese government calls for a ceasefire, and the Coalition goes on the attack

Image of Chris Bowen speaking at COP28

Not phased

What good are nice words about phasing out fossil fuels when Australia continues to expand and export?

From the front page

Kim Williams seen through window with arms half-raised

The interesting Mr Williams

At a time when the ABC faces more pressure than ever before, is its new chair the right person for the job?

Illustration by Jeff Fisher

Letter from Dunkley

As a byelection draws the nation’s focus to the scrappy suburb of the author’s childhood, a visit reveals the damage wrought by the housing crisis

Exterior of the Department of Treasury, Canberra

Tax to grind

Tax reform should not be centred on what we want, but on who we want to be

Rehearsal for the ABC TV show ‘Cooking with Wine’, March 13, 1956

Whose ABC?

Amid questions of relevance and culture war hostilities, the ABC’s charter clearly makes the case for a government-funded national broadcaster