Tuesday, September 8, 2020

Today by Paddy Manning

Great fall
The deterioration of the Australia–China relationship is alarming

Bill Birtles (left) and Mike Smith.

Bill Birtles (left) and Mike Smith. Images via ABC News

Foreign Minister Marise Payne is remaining diplomatic despite China’s provocative move to interrogate two Australian journalists – ABC correspondent Bill Birtles and AFR’s Mike Smith – who have landed home safely after an extraordinary stand-off. As the ABC reports, the saga began early last week, after Chinese authorities claimed the two journalists were persons of interest. The news follows the shocking detention of another Australian journalist, Cheng Lei, who worked for China’s state broadcaster CGTN. “This is a very disappointing series of events,” Payne told 2GB this afternoon, adding, “We will continue to work, in a bilateral sense, guided by our national interest. We will deal with individual issues as they arise, as they have done here.” Nevertheless, the deterioration of Australia’s relationship with China this year – from a war of words over a World Health Organization inquiry into the origins of the pandemic, to claims of “economic coercion” as China put up trade barriers against Australian goods, to the arbitrary detention of Australian citizens – is downright alarming. Australian government ministers cannot place a phone call to their Chinese counterparts, and Australian media organisations have no journalists on the ground in China for the first time since the 1970s. Australians are officially advised against travelling to visit our largest trading partner, and warned they are at risk of arbitrary detention – a situation that cannot last. 

In a statement today, shadow foreign minister Penny Wong was equally restrained, citing a recent speech by the Chinese embassy’s deputy head of mission, Wang Xining, in which he called for “mutual respect” between the two countries. “The media plays a vital role in fostering this respect by deepening understanding, which is vital for a productive relationship,” Wong said. “It is deeply regrettable that there is now no Australian media presence in China. We hope that Australian media organisations will be able to have their people on the ground in China again soon.” At a doorstop press conference in Adelaide today, Wong was asked whether Australia should retaliate in kind, by revoking the visas of journalists from Chinese state-owned media working in Australia. “I think if we are consistent, our position is journalists should be able to undertake your work safely and freely,” answered Wong, “and that is an Australian principle to which we all hold dear.”

For all the diplomacy, we get no sense from the Morrison government of where the Australia–China relationship is heading. Amid naked hostility between the US and China (most recently Attorney General William Barr told Congress that China was a more serious threat to the integrity of November’s presidential election than Russia), Australia has all but picked sides. A group of Coalition and Labor backbenchers known as “the Wolverines” stir the anti-communist pot while the US-funded Australian Strategic Policy Institute dominates media commentary. At the same time, the fate of China under the dictatorship of President Xi Jinping grows ever-more frightening. It is a lose-lose situation. 

“It’s very disappointing to have to leave under those circumstances,” Birtles said pointedly today, “and it’s a relief to be back in a country with a genuine rule of law.” While Birtles and Smith are safe (and news director Gaven Morris pointed out that ABC staff remain on the ground in other roles), Cheng remains in detention. Minister Payne said that embassy officials had been able to visit her once.

The Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance has expressed outrage at China’s heavy-handed treatment of the Australian journalists, saying Cheng’s secret detention was particularly worrying. “It is clear that China, and by extension Hong Kong through the recent National Security Law, is unsafe for foreign journalists,” said federal president Marcus Strom. “These outrageous attacks on press freedom place any foreign correspondents reporting from China at risk. China is isolating itself from the world’s gaze and demonstrating it will not brook any scrutiny of its activities. It threatens and intimidates journalists using ‘national security’ as a catch-all excuse. This is an extremely disappointing development. It has come swiftly, it is extremely aggressive and it will do great harm to China’s reputation around the world.” 

Australia would be much better placed to complain to China if our own free press credentials were stronger. Marise Payne has been silent on the plight of another Australian, WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, now on trial in the UK for the crime of journalism and facing 175 years in jail if the US succeeds in extraditing him. Meanwhile, a brief for the criminal prosecution of ABC investigative reporter Dan Oakes has languished with the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions for more than two months, and the secret trial of whistleblower Witness K and his lawyer Bernard Collaery grinds on. The recent recommendations of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security on press freedom are charitably described as an opportunity missed. If only it rang truer when Payne says, as she did today, that Australia is a strong advocate of freedom of the press. 


An earlier version of this story stated that a brief of evidence for the criminal prosecution of ABC investigative journalist Dan Oakes was languishing on Christian Porters desk. This is incorrect. The brief has been with the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions since early July. Attorney-General Christian Porter has previously stated that he would be seriously disinclinedto sign off on criminal proceedings against a journalist but has declined to call for an end to the proceedings against Oakes despite being urged to do so, including by the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance.   

“I’d say to the prime minister: the worst-case scenario is being open for three or four weeks and then closed down again.”

Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews responds to Scott Morrison’s criticisms of the Victorian recovery roadmap.

“The need to feel comfortable at home has become more necessary than ever. Bunnings has a significant role to play in support [of] this activity and helping Victorians manage their mental health.”

A consumer survey prepared for Bunnings by Quantum Market Research suggests that lockdown restrictions are “a good opportunity to get some jobs done around the house”.

5 Reasons Facebook Is Ditching News (You Won’t Believe Number 3)
After lobbying from the press, the government is trying to force Google and Facebook to pay for journalism. The tech giants have responded by threatening to stop sharing news from Australian outlets. Today, Mike Seccombe on the battle that will shape the future of Australian media.


The proportion of audit fees from companies in the ASX 200 that went to the top three firms – PwC, EY and KPMG – over the past 12 years, according to new analysis.


“Australia faces a $217 billion infrastructure shortfall by 2040 … Australian governments have already committed enough to road and water networks and the biggest problems concern railways and ports.”

The Global Infrastructure Hub, an Australian initiative of the 2014 G20 summit in Brisbane, calls for Australia to build its way out of recession, taking advantage of historically low interest rates.

The list

“On a recent winter’s afternoon, not for the first time, Dr John Gill blamed Scientologists for his personal and professional demise. He had taken the oath just minutes earlier, the glare of the computer screen reflecting off his glasses as he swore, by Almighty God and into the Microsoft Teams videoconferencing app, that he would tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth about the tragic and peculiar events of 50 years ago.”

“In Australia, franchising is often seen as an unwelcome infiltration of American monoculturalism. But as much as we’d like to disbelieve it, franchising is distinctly our culture, perhaps even more so than it is America’s. Australia has more franchises than any other nation on Earth.”

“Middleton says that a week after closing the museum’s doors they opened the Facebook group Bridging the Distance – Sharing our Covid-19 Pandemic Experiences. He sees the group as ‘a civic project. It’s about creating these safe spaces.’ It collects a time line of memories and testimonies from citizens of their everyday life during the pandemic. The thousands of posts it has attracted will inform a future exhibition of unremarkable ephemera related to the health, economic and psychosocial crises of the minute.”

Paddy Manning

Paddy Manning is contributing editor (politics) at The Monthly and has worked for the ABC, Fairfax, Crikey and The Australian. He is the author of Inside the Greens and the unauthorised biography of Malcolm Turnbull, Born To Rule?


The Monthly Today

Image of Treasurer Josh Frydenberg

Tax cuts loom

In Josh Frydenberg’s budget, the Coalition looks like reverting to type

Image of Prime Minister Scott Morrison


On a practical day, the PM got practically none of what he wanted

Image of Co-CEO of Atlassian Mike Cannon-Brookes

A million jobs

A plan to tackle unemployment and climate change is staring the government in the face

Image of Andrew Liveris at the National Press Club today.

Hot air

Businessman Andrew Liveris undercuts his own rhetoric by championing fossil fuels

From the front page

Image of Treasurer Josh Frydenberg

Tax cuts loom

In Josh Frydenberg’s budget, the Coalition looks like reverting to type

Image of the Aboriginal flag

Freeing the flag

Allowing the Aboriginal flag to be used freely is an important step towards self-determination

Image of Dolly Parton

Audio tapestry

A tangle of red tape is robbing us of music podcasts in Australia

In the red

Inside the modern debt-collection industry