The Politics    Monday, September 7, 2020

Roadmap slap

By Paddy Manning

Roadmap slap
For the PM, attacking Victoria is an open-and-shut case

Prime Minister Scott Morrison persists with his risky strategy of championing NSW’s response to COVID-19 and berating Victoria’s. At a Canberra press conference today, to announce that Australia finally has an agreement for almost 85 million doses of two promising coronavirus vaccines, the PM harped on the theme that his home state was providing the “gold standard” of contact tracing, which was the difference between the economy staying open and remaining closed. “I think there is lot to learn from what’s happening in NSW, because they have, frankly, had the largest risks to deal with, and they have demonstrated the best capacity to deal with them and keep their state open.” He continued: “They are the direction I’m strongly urging the country to go in. Because Australia being shut is not success, Australia being open is success.” This is risky for Morrison on two grounds. First, it may entrench perceptions he is the PM for NSW and anger Victorians who will be doing the hard yards in lockdown a while longer. Second, it smacks of hubris when the battle in NSW is far from over and the possibility of a second wave remains very real. Burnet Institute epidemiologist Michael Toole has pointed to South Korea – where cases have recently surged after two months of very low infection rates (similar to those in NSW) – and argues that Sydney needs to do more to avoid a second lockdown, Melbourne-style. Morrison is not going to look smart if NSW falters. 

The smarter approach for any politician outside Victoria would be to show some empathy for the state’s travails – “there but for the grace of God go I”, as Labor leader Anthony Albanese suggested on air today. His health spokesperson, Chris Bowen, at a press conference to welcome the vaccine deal, took the opportunity to question the judgement of the PM, who has taken a hopeful view of the pandemic throughout and has often been dragged into tough action. “Scott Morrison and Josh Frydenberg called on Annastacia Palaszczuk to open her borders to Victoria,” said Bowen. “She was right, and they were wrong. When they’ve called for schools to be opened and other restrictions to be eased more quickly, they haven’t been vindicated by the passage of time. When they supported Clive Palmer’s court case against Mark McGowan, they were wrong and Mark McGowan was right. They’ve got it wrong at multiple turns and I don’t think it’s helpful for federal Liberals … to be criticising governments of any persuasion at state level for making difficult decisions based on the best health advice available.”

Morrison constantly says that NSW’s contact tracing capability is better than Victoria’s, but he never quite puts his finger on why. It’s not just about how many contact tracers are on the job, Morrison said today, “it’s how it’s tasked and how it’s integrated with its information systems, and then how that sits as part of the broader emergency-management function of the government.” Health secretary Brendan Murphy put some flesh on the bones this afternoon, saying that NSW was the exemplar with “a proud history of many, many years of advanced investment in public health. They’ve had good systems. They’ve had embedded public health units in all their local health districts. They’ve had very good outbreak-response teams … It’s not just about tracing.” Murphy added that Victoria had invested hugely in this capability over the past few months and was in a much stronger position now than when the pandemic began.  

Unhappy with Victoria’s cautious recovery roadmap, the prime minister seems to be hoping that he can bully the Andrews government into hurrying things along. Today, Morrison said the federal government would review the modelling that underpins the state strategy, adding, “I’m sure the Victorian government would welcome that interrogation of that. We will be providing constructive feedback on that plan. We will be sitting down with industry. We will be sitting down with business through our national coordinating mechanism, which is run out of the Department of Home Affairs, and we’ll listen carefully, and we’ll faithfully convey all of that feedback.” But with national cabinet fracturing around him, the PM will need to tread carefully. 

“The attempt to extradite Assange is designed to stifle dissent, sending a chill through the ranks of investigative journalists worldwide. If Assange can be prosecuted for exposing evidence of US war crimes, so can any journalist anywhere in the world.”

Andrew Fowler, author of The Most Dangerous Man in the World: Julian Assange and WikiLeaks’ Fight for Freedom, comments on the case of the Wikileaks founder, who is set to attend a US extradition hearing.

“You keep sticking to that line … no one believes you anymore, Kristina.”

NSW Labor senator Deborah O’Neill accuses shadow home affairs minister Kristina Keneally – a rival for a spot on the upper house ticket – of leaking against her (which Keneally denies).

The doctors, the Scientologists and the journalist
A court has been re-examining controversial psychiatric treatments used in a Sydney hospital in the 1960s, which drew the attention of the Church of Scientology and led to a royal commission. Today, Lane Sainty on what happened at Chelmsford, and the journalist caught in the middle 30 years on.


The number of politics, courts, crime and sport stories being offered daily by the recently relaunched Australian Associated Press, which today instigated a crowdfunding appeal.

“Ordinarily, incremental changes are considered on an individual basis, and this may not be the best way to consider a whole-of-market redesign. The value of considering a broader program of reform enables a systems-thinking approach to be taken, so design elements can be optimised together.”

The Energy Security Board, chaired by respected former public servant Kerry Schott, opens consultation on a redesign of the country’s energy system post-2025.

The list

“[Katerina] Bryant is an Adelaide-based writer who, at the age of 24, started experiencing psychogenic non-epileptic seizures – which, she has learnt, is the modern, polite way of saying ‘hysterical seizures’. The depersonalisation that overcomes her slows her world down to a crawl and makes familiar objects and faces seem strange and new.”

“At least three writers have previously attempted to write [Billy] McMahon’s biography, but all gave up in despair, not because the subject refused to cooperate but because he wouldn’t leave them alone. McMahon was, if nothing else, indefatigable. When Gough Whitlam was asked which quality he most admired in McMahon, he unhesitatingly nominated – in a rare moment of tact – his persistence.”

“Hui and her kindergarten’s parent committee have been keeping an eye on the books since January, trying to work out how many deep cleans they can afford before folding. A single clean would cost $6000. ‘I’d say two cleans and then we’re finished,’ she says. At the gate, she and her staff police the permits that allow essential workers and permitted workers to use the centre during lockdown. It’s a role none of them wants.”

Paddy Manning

Paddy Manning is contributing editor at The Monthly and the author of Inside the Greens and Body Count.

The Politics

Image of Anthony Albanese

Whither progress?

In a threatening climate, the first full year of the Albanese government has been defined by caution and incrementalism

6 News Australia interviews Gen Z Party founder Thomas Rex Dolan. Image via X.

Grift of the gab

Strange things are happening to our political system, and it’s time the major parties started paying attention

Voting results displayed on two large screens at the UN General Assembly’s tenth emergency special session

Ceaseless politics

The Albanese government calls for a ceasefire, and the Coalition goes on the attack

Image of Chris Bowen speaking at COP28

Not phased

What good are nice words about phasing out fossil fuels when Australia continues to expand and export?

From the front page

Kim Williams seen through window with arms half-raised

The interesting Mr Williams

At a time when the ABC faces more pressure than ever before, is its new chair the right person for the job?

Exterior of the Department of Treasury, Canberra

Tax to grind

Tax reform should not be centred on what we want, but on who we want to be

Rehearsal for the ABC TV show ‘Cooking with Wine’, March 13, 1956

Whose ABC?

Amid questions of relevance and culture war hostilities, the ABC’s charter clearly makes the case for a government-funded national broadcaster

Tony McNamara in New York City, January 2024

Pure things: Tony McNamara

How the Australian screenwriter of ‘Poor Things’, who cut his teeth on shows such as ‘The Secret Life of Us’, earnt his second Oscar nomination