Tuesday, March 3, 2020

Today by Paddy Manning

PM, brazen
Scott Morrison has been caught out over sports rorts

© Mick Tsikas / AAP Images

Smoking gun over sports rorts? So what. Prime Minister Scott Morrison admits nothing, apologises for nothing, and just continues to defy any accountability for telling manifest untruths about the role of his office in the Community Sport Infrastructure Grant Program. We now know, straight from the evidence in Senate Estimates, that the prime minister’s office was deciding which grants would be awarded, and which wouldn’t – even after the election was called, in a clear breach of the caretaker convention. Morrison continues to defy accountability, even though he surely knows that we know his office was in the thick of the rorting of the scheme, because he is betting that the public have tarred all politicians with the same brush a long time ago. To make sure of it, in his own defence in Question Time, the PM threw some dirt back at Labor, about an apparent breach in 2013, claiming $6.5 million in government advertisements targeting people-smugglers were running in The Sydney Morning Herald in the caretaker period, and saying the Opposition leader “can only throw mud because he sits in a puddle of mud”. That’s it. A kindergarten-grade debate, in our national parliament.

To backtrack a little, Labor came into Question Time today convinced that last night’s Senate Estimates testimony from the Australian National Audit Office’s Brian Boyd was a smoking gun, including that changes were still being made to the list of funded projects “at the request of the prime minister’s office” after the election was called on the morning of April 11. As Opposition business manager Tony Burke said in a fiery doorstop this morning: “One project that was going to make the cut was cut. One project that was going to miss out suddenly finds its way in. And then, at 12.46, hours after we had entered caretaker, another nine projects get added and another project misses out. All the time, while Scott Morrison is claiming that he had nothing to do with it, his office is directing Senator McKenzie to make changes and those changes were made.” The prime minister has repeatedly said – and said again in the parliament today – that the only involvement of his office was to pass on information to then sports minister Bridget McKenzie, supposedly the ultimate decision-maker. Burke said that not only was this misleading, it was a breach of the caretaker convention.

“Let’s not forget why caretaker exists,” said Burke. “The caretaker provisions are there to stop governments from using taxpayers’ money as though it belongs to their political party during a campaign. Those rules were broken. Those rules were broken in a sports rorts scandal that has shown a corrupt process going all the way through, office after office, right through to the office of the prime minister of Australia. People have wondered up till now, will there be a smoking gun? Will there be proof of the involvement of the prime minister of Australia? Last night we got there.”

At a minimum, the prime minister should correct the record, Burke said. Fat chance. When the evidence from Senate Estimates was put to him in parliament in question after question by Anthony Albanese today, the PM either threw mud back or rejected Albanese’s assertions, or refused to answer because the Labor leader was simply restating information that was before the Senate – every tactic in the book, in short, to insist black was white. And using the government’s numbers to again crush the final inevitable censure motion, Morrison got away with it.

Worse, we have been here before – just last night in fact, when Energy and Emissions Reduction Minister Angus Taylor sat smugly through an interview on ABC’s 7.30, unbelievably claiming some vindication from the fact that two police forces had looked at the alleged doctoring of the City of Sydney document that was provided to The Daily Telegraph, even though we learnt this week the AFP declined to investigate and interviewed neither him nor Lord Mayor Clover Moore.

Worst of all worsts, there is not even light at the end of the tunnel because, if you listen carefully to Attorney-General Christian Porter on RN Breakfast this morning, we can be fairly confident that the government’s proposed Commonwealth Integrity Commission would not be able to investigate the kind of behaviour we have seen with both the sports rorts affair or #angusgate. 

One thing is certain: changing the government will not be enough. It will take structural reform to end the worsening cycle of trashing the parliament and trashing the office of prime minister.

“We had a mass murderer come to this country from Australia. Did we make a song and dance with Australia about that? It was the worst tragedy we’ve ever had, 51 people lost their lives … far worse than Port Arthur. And nobody in my country sought to abuse Australia about that. That’s my point. We want a fair go and we want a thing called respect.”

New Zealand Deputy PM Winston Peters schools Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton on statecraft.

“The president of Burundi asked me if I’d stand as a consulate for Burundi in Australia. It took a while for the Australian government to recognise that, but eventually they did, and now we have a relationship on a diplomatic scale with Australia and Burundi.”

Barry Court, husband of tennis player and Pentecostal worshipper Margaret, explains how he became honorary consul to the African regime of Burundi, which has been investigated for crimes against humanity.

Could we end domestic violence?
The murder of Hannah Clarke and her children has put Australia’s failure to grapple with domestic violence back on the national agenda. Today, Bri Lee on the changes we need to make to keep women and children safe.

The total value of the federal government programs that appear to have been rorted, according to a tally by The New Daily columnist Michael Pascoe.

“There could be the declaration of what are called Human Health Response Zones, and that could mean that there are specific requirements for screening measures for people going in and out of such a zone. So, for instance, in a peak presentation period, it would be likely that you’d have things that are called fever clinics which are designed to help people recover from the acute fever that comes with coronavirus and people entering and leaving those zones could be subject to requirements that are compulsive.”

Attorney-General Christian Porter outlines some of the possible measures to combat the coronavirus pandemic under the Biosecurity Act 2015, which replaced the century-old quarantine laws five years ago.

The list

“In my corner of inner-city Melbourne, a warbling magpie on the wire announces the morning. The local cafe is full; later there will be skateboarders and kissing couples in the park. When I walk the dog in the late afternoon, the shouts of cricketers rise from the oval, and the advancing evening is so lovely – even this summer – that I struggle to reconcile the irrefutable evidence of the science with the immediate evidence of my senses. Civilisational collapse, because of a change in the weather?”

“This year, the government will spend more than $41 billion on tax concessions for superannuation with the stated purpose of helping people save for their retirement. But the way the rules are designed give the vast majority of that money to people who will already retire comfortably, while providing next to nothing to those with the lowest incomes and the lowest super balances.”

“For the 70th Berlin International Film Festival, expectations were unusually high. The old order was gone, overturned at last: let a thousand flowers bloom! Recruited following a stint at the Locarno Film Festival, incoming head Carlo Chatrian clearly recognised the need to renew an event that had, in recent years, been accused of slipping into irrelevancy. Still, a few grumblings could be heard as the event kicked off.”

Paddy Manning

Paddy Manning is contributing editor (politics) at The Monthly and has worked for the ABC, Fairfax, Crikey and The Australian. He is the author of Body Count: How Climate Change Is Killing Us, Inside the Greens and Born To Rule: The Unauthorised Biography of Malcolm Turnbull.


The Monthly Today

Image of New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and ACT Chief Minister Andrew Barr

Labor and the Greens

In NZ and the ACT, the two parties have shown they can work together

Digging in

The Liberal Party rallies round Gladys Berejiklian

Image of Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews

Back off

Daniel Andrews should be left to act on health advice alone

‘Woo hoo!’

Berejiklian is implicated in her former partner’s corrupt conduct

From the front page

Image of Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews with screenshots from #IStandWithDan

Hopelessly devoted to Dan

The government is your servant, not your friend

‘The Lying Life of Adults’ by Elena Ferrante

The Neapolitan author returns to characters driven by compulsions and tensions of class

Image of New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and ACT Chief Minister Andrew Barr

Labor and the Greens

In NZ and the ACT, the two parties have shown they can work together

Images of Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese

Bury the lead

Newspoll delivers an unwanted result for the Murdoch media