Friday, December 6, 2019

Today by Paddy Manning

Failing our kids
A decade of debate about school funding, and we’re going backwards

Photo by Feliphe Schiarolli on Unsplash

Today’s interim report of an independent expert panel reviewing NAPLAN on behalf of the Victorian, New South Wales, Queensland and ACT governments caps a run of bad news showing that our increasingly inequitable school system is failing. “The status quo is not an option for NAPLAN,” Victorian Education Minister James Merlino told Nine Media. Potential changes in the report include halving the number of tests students sit and restricting comparisons on the My School website. That comes after the OECD’s Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) delivered the gloomy finding that the performance of Australian students was declining in the areas of reading, maths and science. “We need to turn this around and turn it around quickly,” said the Coalition’s still-newish education minister, Dan Tehan. After almost a decade of debate about implementing a sector-blind, needs-based funding model through the initial Gonski review, commissioned under Julia Gillard, and Gonski 2.0, delivered under then prime minister Malcolm Turnbull, it is an indictment on the political system that instead of making progress we’ve gone backwards.

The Coalition’s mantra is that it has delivered record school funding, but after stripping out wage inflation and growth in student numbers, the claim is ill founded, according to Sue Thomson, deputy chief executive for research at the Australian Council for Educational Research, who joined an insightful panel conversation on RN Breakfast this morning. Citing research by the Grattan Institute, Thomson got straight to the nub of the problem: “There actually hasn’t been a huge increase in funding to schools, and actually 80 per cent of that funding has gone to advantaged schools rather than disadvantaged schools, so the funding is certainly something that needs to be looked at.” Steven Kolber, a teacher at Brunswick Secondary College, a state school in Melbourne, said much the same thing: the PISA findings were not a surprise, there was a growing gap between high achievers and disadvantaged students, and “it’s the distribution of funding that needs to be addressed”.

Unfortunately the wrong lessons are being learnt from the debate. The government argues that more funding is not the solution to declining standards, while continuing to funnel hundreds of millions of dollars to elite private schools engaged in an arms race to build ever-more lavish facilities, in an ongoing insult to the hundreds of disadvantaged school communities around the country. Education ministers meet next week in Alice Springs, and Tehan this week used the PISA results to push his National School Reform Agreement – which has met resistance from state and territory ministers concerned by inadequate funding for public schools – and to include phonics as part of teacher training. That will at least make Daily Telegraph columnist Miranda Devine happy, as she has been pushing for it for more than a decade. “My message to the state and territory education ministers is this: leave the teachers’ union talking points at home and be ambitious,” Tehan said. “Our school systems also need to de-clutter their curriculums and get back to basics.”

This week, shadow education minister Tanya Plibersek lambasted the worst results in reading, maths, and science since international testing began, and called on the government to say how it would fix the problem. The sad reality, according to the ALP campaign review, is that the $14 billion extra in school funding, which Plibersek promised ahead of the last election, was one of a series of promises that “played directly into the Coalition’s narrative of big, risky spending that would have to be paid for with big economy-wrecking taxes”.

The currency of the Gonski school funding model has been debased, and the point has gotten lost in years of partisan tit-for-tat about ancient spending commitments long forgotten. Sure, more school funding alone is not the entire answer – nobody argues that it is – but that doesn’t mean we should persist with an unfair model that leaves disadvantaged kids falling further and further behind.

“I am completely astounded. When you look at the shocking statistics relating to Aboriginal women and family violence – 34 times more likely to be hospitalised, 10 times more likely to be murdered from violent assault – it beggars belief that this would happen … This government just wants to get rid of or attack as many peak Aboriginal organisations as possible.”

Opposition Indigenous Australians spokesperson Linda Burney responds to news that Minister Ken Wyatt has defunded the National Family Violence Prevention and Legal Services Forum, the only advocacy body for Aboriginal victims of family violence, for a saving of $244,000.

“We’re winning so much, you’ll be sick of it by next year.”

Prime Minister Scott Morrison channels US President Donald Trump in a speech to Coalition MPs and staff at last night’s Christmas drinks at Parliament House.

Jacqui Lambie’s secret deal
Jacqui Lambie says she has a deal with the government to repeal medevac. She won’t say what it is, and the government says it never existed. Paul Bongiorno on the end of another year in politics.


The proportion by which ANZ aims to reduce its lending to the thermal coal industry  by 2025, according to an internal email seen by the ABC.

“Nobody can advocate or advertise hate or violence on Facebook and we remove any violations as soon as we become aware.”

Facebook responds to an investigation revealing a covert plot to harvest Islamophobia for profit. The group responsible targeted high-profile Muslim women around the world, including Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi.

The list

“Not since The Beatles had Britain experienced so virulent a fever. It’s doubtful it ever will again. I suggest to Liam Gallagher that they didn’t just seem comfortable with that fame, they gave the impression that it was the fulfilment of destiny. ‘But privately,’ I ask, ‘what did celebrity do? Did it become claustrophobic, or weird? What did it feel like?’”

“Ghost stories have haunted the screen since the earliest frames of cinema, itself a medium of psychic transferral – spectral light beamed through celluloid – through which the dead can manifest across time. The phantom thread winding from Méliès to Assayas connects all manner of tricksters and malevolents, the displaced and the vengeful, but few films have communed with the beyond quite like Mati Diop’s Atlantics, an uncanny seance in which shipwrecked souls return to inhabit those they’ve loved and left behind.”

“Having met as nine-year-olds playing for the Northern District Cricket Club in Sydney, before sharing the wicketkeeping gloves in the under 11s, Alyssa Healy and Mitchell Starc are just the third married couple to play Test cricket, and Australia’s first. Chances are you’ll know more about Starc, though, for sport is still a place where netball, gymnastics and perhaps Serena Williams are among the few exceptions to the general men-have-higher-profiles-while-playing-the-same-game rule.”

Paddy Manning

Paddy Manning is contributing editor (politics) at The Monthly and has worked for the ABC, Fairfax, Crikey and The Australian. He is the author of Inside the Greens and the unauthorised biography of Malcolm Turnbull, Born To Rule?


The Monthly Today

Image of prime minister Gough Whitlam addressing reporters outside Parliament after his dismissal by governor-general John Kerr on November 11, 1975.

Palace fetters

An elected Australian government could still be dismissed by the Queen

Image of Treasurer Josh Frydenberg

Cluster struck

A second wave of COVID-19 cases is dragging the country down

Image of Barnaby Joyce

‘It’s our fault’

Barnaby Joyce says Nats to blame for the Coalition’s Eden-Monaro defeat

Welcome flat

Australia will not take tens of thousands of Hong Kongers

From the front page

Image of prime minister Gough Whitlam addressing reporters outside Parliament after his dismissal by governor-general John Kerr on November 11, 1975.

Palace fetters

An elected Australian government could still be dismissed by the Queen

David Gulpilil at the opening night of the Sydney Film Festival on June 8, 2016.

The many faces of David Gulpilil

Gulpilil’s surrealist performances reveal our collective unconscious

Still from ‘Contempt’

The death of cool: Michel Piccoli, 1925–2020

Re-watching the films of the most successful screen actor of the 20th century

Image of Treasurer Josh Frydenberg

Cluster struck

A second wave of COVID-19 cases is dragging the country down