Friday, June 29, 2018

Today by Paddy Manning

Spycatcher redux
The PM once defended a whistleblower like Witness K


At the tail end of the Cold War, when the supposed threat to our very way of life was communism, not terrorism, a young lawyer called Malcolm Turnbull achieved global fame as a defender of free speech in the celebrated Spycatcher case. The case has some striking parallels with the prosecution of lawyer and former ACT Attorney-General Bernard Collaery and his client, former spy Witness K, revealed sensationally yesterday under parliamentary privilege by independent Tasmanian MP Andrew Wilkie. The laying of criminal charges under Howard-era terrorism laws was approved by Attorney-General Christian Porter, and came just as the government succeeded yesterday in rushing draconian espionage and foreign influence laws through parliament. In a stirring interview this morning, Wilkie told ABC RN Breakfast that the government was flexing its legal muscle: “since 9-11 there’s been more than 60 terrorism laws pass the parliament – just this week we’ve had two more – many of them are excessive and unnecessary, and many of them go to stifling free speech”.

The AG warned against commentary on the Witness K case yesterday, so let us go to back to 1986, when Turnbull was engaged by the publisher of Spycatcher. The book was a memoir, written by former MI5 agent Peter Wright, who had moved to Australia. Wright, the whistleblower in this case, alleged all kinds of criminal conduct by members of the British security services – analogous to the allegations of illegal conduct that Witness K made against his employer, ASIS. As Turnbull wrote in his book on the case, The Spycatcher Trial, the conduct ranged “from conspiracy to murder through burgling diplomatic premises to switching number plates in breach of the English Road Traffic Act”. The most serious allegation was treason, in an MI5 operation to destabilise the government of Harold Wilson. Serious as they were, the allegations were not new: almost all were contained in previous works, including journalist Chapman Pincher’s Their Trade Is Treachery, for which Wright himself had been a key confidential source.

Wright was a paranoiac anti-communist, with extreme right-wing views, who believed the former long-time head of MI5, the late Roger Hollis, had been a Russian spy whom the British establishment conspired to protect. Wright was an admirer of Thatcher: Turnbull wrote that “his only complaint against [her] was that she was insufficiently alert to the perils of international communism”.

Margaret Thatcher’s government wanted to make an example of Wright, nonetheless, and tried to suppress publication of his memoir as a breach of the Official Secrets Act. Thatcher’s purpose was purely political, Turnbull argued, and had nothing to do with national security. As he wrote in a letter to Australia’s then attorney-general, Lionel Bowen: “In our view the British Government’s only motive for seeking to suppress the book is that information in the book is evidence that [Thatcher] … made a false statement to the House of Commons in March 1981 concerning the investigations into Sir Roger Hollis. In other words the efforts to suppress this book are essentially … to prevent political embarrassment.”

Turnbull was only 32 when he took on the British government. He had just set up his own law firm, having left the bar after becoming very unpopular with his colleagues who resented his use of the media – contrary to rules against touting – to defend his client Kerry Packer from allegations aired before the Costigan royal commission. Turnbull flatly rejected those criticisms: “While I think lawyers have their main function in the courts, if their client’s cause requires media appearances, they should not shrink from them.” Bernard Collaery would no doubt agree.

The Spycatcher case attracted global publicity and, without going into the details, Turnbull won. The trial made Turnbull’s name, and is a key reason he is prime minister today – certainly his subsequent work on the republican movement, or advising on the sale of failed insurer HIH, did not help his career in the Liberal Party. Publication of Spycatcher, which sold millions worldwide, was a victory for free speech (notwithstanding that the memoir in question was forgettable tripe), and during the trial Turnbull reflected on the nature of free speech, raising the example of maverick politician Winston Churchill who breached the Official Secrets Act in 1936 to warn of the Nazis’ rearmament:

“The public interest in free speech is not just in truthful speech, in correct speech, in fair speech, in speech one point at a time and never to be repeated. The interest is in the debate. You see, every person who has ultimately changed the course of history has started off being unpopular. When the Australian Workers’ Union was founded under a tree in the bush, when unionists were not permitted to even go on to squatters’ properties, there were plenty of people and, I am afraid to say plenty of judges, in those far off days who supported the establishment against those people. They spoke out, and they spoke again, and they said the same thing a great deal more than once and finally they changed history and there are few people today that would say the struggle of the labour movement in this country and the struggle of other people who have been unpopular – Winston Churchill if you like – was not in the public interest, because ultimately these ideas are tested in debate and it is that debate in which there is a public interest …”

Hear, hear.

since this morning

Opposition leader Bill Shorten has backflipped on his captain’s call to repeal legislated tax cuts for small and medium businesses, The Australian reports [$], after a shadow cabinet meeting in Sydney today.

British company BAE Systems has beat off fierce competition from rival Spanish and Italian designs to win a $35 billion contract to produce nine high-tech “Hunter class” anti-submarine frigates, with construction by ASC shipbuilding beginning in Adelaide in 2020.

Crikey’s Bernard Keane writes [$] that the Director of Public Prosecutions’ decision to prosecute Bernard Collaery for talking to the ABC “raises serious questions about the agenda behind the prosecution”.

in case you missed it

The AFR’s Phillip Coorey writes [$] that “after five years of remarkable unity, there are dark mutterings inside Labor about the need at least for ‘a conversation’ regarding the leadership should it lose one or both of Longman or Braddon on super Saturday”. Coorey warns that the party should “think long and hard before contemplating going down that road again”.

Michelle Grattan writes that “For the first time in [Shorten’s] leadership, the possibility of a serious threat to his position is there, resting in the hands of these voters in two marginal ALP seats in the south and north of the country.”

The Guardian’s Amanda Meade reports that “one of Australia’s most accomplished television journalists, Liz Jackson, has died aged 67. A giant of ABC current affairs, Jackson died in her sleep while on holiday in Greece with her partner, Martin Butler.”

by Craig Mathieson
‘Queer Eye’ has its finger firmly on America’s jagged pulse
The uncommonly caring makeover show returns to Netflix for a second season

by Richard Denniss
Grandfathering the Australian dream
House prices, insecure work and growing debts … Who can afford a stake in today’s society?

Paddy Manning

Paddy Manning is contributing editor (politics) at The Monthly and has worked for the ABC, Fairfax, Crikey and The Australian. He is the author of Inside the Greens and the unauthorised biography of Malcolm Turnbull, Born To Rule?


The Monthly Today

Image of Minister for Skills Michaelia Cash


The looming training overhaul will need to be watched closely

Image of chair of the National COVID-19 Coordination Commission and former Fortescue Metals chief executive Neville Power

Building back better?

The government’s pandemic response is taking a familiar shape

An unavoidable recession

The pandemic got us in, the treasurer must get us out

Image of protest against police violence in Minneapolis, Minnesota on May 26, 2020

Black Lives Matter

Australia should draw lessons from the riots in the US

From the front page

Image of Minister for Skills Michaelia Cash


The looming training overhaul will need to be watched closely

Cold was the ground: ‘Sorry for Your Trouble’

Richard Ford delivers an elegant collection of stories of timeworn men and women contemplating the end

Photograph of Malcolm Turnbull

Surrounded by pygmies: Malcolm Turnbull’s ‘A Bigger Picture’

The former PM’s memoir fails to reckon with his fatal belief that all Australians shared his vision

Child's illustration

The screens that ate school

What do we really know about the growing presence of Google, Apple, Microsoft and more in the education system?