August 2014

Arts & Letters

Ghosts of R&B past

By Anwen Crawford
Timbaland and Boyz II Men haunt FKA Twigs’ ‘LP1’ and How To Dress Well’s ‘What Is This Heart?’

A spectre is haunting contemporary pop music – the spectre of Timbaland. America’s R&B super-producer – real name Timothy Mosley – is still very much alive, but his astonishing work at the millennium’s turn with artists like Missy Elliott, Aaliyah and Ginuwine hovers in the atmosphere. Its futuristic promises have not so far been improved upon, not even by Timbaland himself. Timbaland took the plush exterior of R&B and stripped it bare; his audaciously minimal arrangements twitch and stutter, suggesting the distracted, nervous disposition of the digital habitué a good ten years in advance of the smartphone. His chief protégé Aaliyah, who might have been bigger even than Beyoncé, died in a plane crash at the age of 22, after filming a video clip in the Bahamas for ‘Rock the Boat’. Produced by Timbaland, the song was released after her death in 2001.

‘Two Weeks’, the lead single from FKA Twigs’ debut album, LP1, released this month, exists in the long shadow of Aaliyah and Timbaland’s collaboration, and in particular their 1998 song ‘Are You That Somebody?’ Despite – or more likely because – of that debt, ‘Two Weeks’ is surely one of 2014’s best songs. The music moves like a sliding puzzle, set in motion by thunderous, rolling kick drum and shot through with snare patterns, with openings in the sound where you couldn’t have quite predicted them to be. Like Aaliyah before her, FKA Twigs sounds best when the sweetness of her soprano is offset by a pronounced syncopation, and her voice here is layered so that multiple Twigs seem to be singing against one another.

Whole phrases occasionally gleam through the vocal stacking. “Motherfucker, get your mouth open / You know you’re mine” is one, though it’s hard to be sure. “My thighs are apart for when you’re ready to breathe in” is another. ‘Two Weeks’ is a success because of the confidence with which it embraces both pop songcraft and eroticism, while rendering each as a surprising, capricious force. If only the rest of LP1 met the same standard.

FKA Twigs, born Tahliah Barnett, is a 26-year-old British musician and dancer who began attracting notice in late 2012 when she uploaded her first recording, EP1, to the music streaming website Bandcamp. A series of striking videos, one for each track on EP1 and its 2013 follow-up EP2 (Twigs’ titles are nothing if not functional), was made available on YouTube. FKA Twigs is as much a visual as a musical project. Her early songs were highly reminiscent of Tricky, one of British music’s most taciturn yet brilliant figures. ‘Weak Spot’, from EP1, shares Tricky’s whispered delivery and paranoid atmosphere. ‘Ache’, from the same release, has a cut-up vocal track that renders an otherwise banal lyric – “I ache for you” – as a mechanical tic, as if desire were the result of a glitch in the body’s central processing unit.

This melding of human and machine has, until now, been central to the FKA Twigs aesthetic. ‘Water Me’, the stand-out track from EP2, borrows its main vocal effect – a series of staccato vowel sounds – from Laurie Anderson’s landmark work of avant-pop, 1981’s ‘O Superman’. The video, in turn, references Sinead O’Connor’s iconic performance in ‘Nothing Compares 2 U’ (1990), though the tear rolling down Twigs’ cheek is digitally animated, and the proportions of her face grow more unreal as the video progresses. “He won’t make love to me now / Not now I’ve set the fee,” she sings, sounding like an abandoned automaton. “He told me I was so small / I told him ‘Water me’.” The song, produced by the Venezuelan-born, New York–based Arca, manages to be aloof and vulnerable at the same time: Arca brought a similar combination of qualities to his production work on Kanye West’s Yeezus.

The bulk of LP1 leaves FKA Twigs stranded somewhere between the stark idiosyncrasies of her early songs and a more generic pop sensuality. Her breathy vocal tone suggests sadness and pleasure simultaneously, but the weaker tracks on LP1 fail to press on this nexus. ‘Hours’, with its refrain “I could kiss you for hours”, could have been vampiric but instead is merely downcast. Aaliyah, who played the vampire queen Akasha in the cult horror flick Queen of the Damned, released six months after her death, still reigns over this R&B underworld.

Tom Krell, an American musician a few years older than FKA Twigs, has recently released his third album under the moniker How To Dress Well, What Is This Heart? “Worn upon my sleeve” is clearly Krell’s answer to that question. Since debuting in 2010 with the album Love Remains, How To Dress Well has performed an emotional transparency that is either totally sincere or utterly cynical, or both.

It’s hard to imagine How To Dress Well in any era but our own. His music is a ghostly amalgam of R&B influences that relies on collective memory to activate its power, and where FKA Twigs has used her online presence, particularly her videos, to cultivate a more old-fashioned, star-in-the-making mystique, How To Dress Well shares and over-shares via the feedback loop of social media. What he seems to give of himself, emotionally, his fans give back to him, with added interest.

The best track on Love Remains was ‘You Won’t Need Me Where I’m Goin’, which is not much more than a vocal line surrounded by digital distortion. It sounds like it was recorded on a mobile phone, and it might well have been. With each subsequent release Krell has emerged a little more from beneath his lo-fi security blanket; What Is This Heart? has recognisable instruments, including acoustic guitar and a string section, recorded cleanly.

How To Dress Well recalls a slightly earlier R&B era than FKA Twigs, reaching past Timbaland to the velvety early ’90s, when divas like Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston roamed the earth and leading men were not afraid to cry. His lodestar, I am guessing, is Mariah Carey and Boyz II Men’s 1995 duet ‘One Sweet Day’, which spent 16 weeks at the top of the Billboard Hot 100 chart in the US. “And I know you’re shining down on me from heaven / Like so many friends we’ve lost along the way,” the singers warble, lachrymose and nearly irresistible, “And I know eventually we’ll be together, one sweet day.” The second How To Dress Well album was called Total Loss, partly in tribute to the death of Krell’s best friend – it’s a surprise that he hasn’t yet covered ‘One Sweet Day’, though many of his songs try to approximate it.

More often than not Krell sings in falsetto: his best song to date is ‘& It Was U’, from Total Loss, an irrepressible slice of doo-wop harmonising which begins with only a metronomic click for accompaniment. It sounds like a one-man Jodeci, the hugely popular ’90s R&B quartet. The strain of falsetto singing creates an immediate vulnerability – the singer is almost literally hurting – and Krell conveys the effort but not the erotic urgency of falsetto singers who have preceded him. Unlike Prince, whose voice can suggest total surrender to the object of his adoration, How To Dress Well is a curiously sexless musical project.

Krell recently named Bruce Springsteen’s bleak masterpiece Nebraska (1982) as his favourite record, though that album, which enacts a specific mourning for the devastated working class of Ronald Reagan’s America, is a long way removed from What Is This Heart? Springsteen’s album is possessed by the voices of men who stand no chance of escaping their own hardscrabble futures, and so choose to destroy themselves in the ugliest ways possible. By contrast, What Is This Heart? closes with the words “This world is such a pretty thing”. How To Dress Well is not haunted, only sentimental – an addictive quality, though not an admirable one.

Anwen Crawford

Anwen Crawford is The Monthly’s music critic.

FKA Twigs. © David Burton

August 2014

From the front page

An unavoidable recession

The pandemic got us in, the treasurer must get us out

Child's illustration

The screens that ate school

What do we really know about the growing presence of Google, Apple, Microsoft and more in the education system?

Image of protest against police violence in Minneapolis, Minnesota on May 26, 2020

Black Lives Matter

Australia should draw lessons from the riots in the US

Image of Australians queuing at Centrelink in Brisbane.

Moral bankruptcy

Robodebt stemmed from the false ideological division between the deserving and undeserving poor, but the government still clings to moralistic language

In This Issue


Must we choose between climate-change action and freedom of speech?

The science is clear, but the way forward is not

The Art Gallery of New South Wales

Art Gallery NSW’s Michael Brand

Adventures in the artefact business


Australia’s $60 billion submarine dilemma

A decision on our underwater fleet cannot be put off much longer

Margaret Inamuka

The women of Papua New Guinea’s village courts

Being a magistrate in the Eastern Highlands is not for the faint of heart

More in Arts & Letters

Photograph of Malcolm Turnbull

Surrounded by pygmies: Malcolm Turnbull’s ‘A Bigger Picture’

The former PM’s memoir fails to reckon with his fatal belief that all Australians shared his vision

Still from ‘The Assistant’

Her too: ‘The Assistant’

Melbourne-born, New York–based filmmaker Kitty Green’s powerfully underplayed portrait of Hollywood’s abusive culture

Photograph of Dua Lipa

Snap-back: Dua Lipa’s ‘Future Nostalgia’

The British singer’s serendipitous album delivers shining pop with a reigning attitude of fortitude

Still from ‘The Platform’

Consolations in isolation: ‘The Platform’ and ‘Free in Deed’

What is the future of cinema without cinemas?

More in Music

Photograph of Dua Lipa

Snap-back: Dua Lipa’s ‘Future Nostalgia’

The British singer’s serendipitous album delivers shining pop with a reigning attitude of fortitude

Image of Cable Ties

The ripple effect: Cable Ties’ ‘Far Enough’

A big year turned on its head for the Melbourne band

Image of Stormzy

Grime boss: Stormzy

The rapper and MC’s second album ‘Heavy Is the Head’ is another triumphant step bringing black British culture forward

Image of Use No Hooks, circa 1979

The future was foreclosed: Post-punk and Use No Hooks’ ‘The Job’

Energetic cross-genre experiments power a scant retrospective from members of Melbourne’s ‘little band’ scene

Read on

Image of Australians queuing at Centrelink in Brisbane.

Moral bankruptcy

Robodebt stemmed from the false ideological division between the deserving and undeserving poor, but the government still clings to moralistic language

Image of Gough Whitlam in October 1975

It’s about time

The High Court’s landmark ruling on the ‘Palace Papers’ is a win for Australian social democracy

Image of Robyn Davidson

Something mythic

For Robyn Davidson, her acclaimed memoir ‘Tracks’ was an act of freedom whose reception hemmed her in

COVID-19 versus human rights

The virus is the latest excuse for governments to slash and burn the individual rights of prisoners