The view from Billinudgel

Nats in the ranks
Turnbull may have an ally in Barnaby Joyce, but the Nationals are a broad church.


When the New South Wales Nationals leader John Barilaro called for Malcolm Turnbull’s resignation last week, it was simple for Turnbull’s federal allies to dismiss it as just another distraction – just another frustrated voice howling into the empty air.

Barnaby Joyce and Mathias Cormann said it was unhelpful and Julie Bishop said that Barilaro was not in her party room, so it was irrelevant.

Turnbull himself accused Barilaro of sucking up to the prime minister’s old enemy, the shock jock Alan Jones. Turnbull says he’s enjoying himself, and while his smile may be becoming a bit strained, there is no hint that he intends to assuage the discontent.

But it is not as simple as that. There are ominous signs that Barilaro’s intervention may become a catalyst for an insurgency – not yet a fully formed rebellion, but a game changer in what has become a political impasse.

Barilaro is not just another fringe dweller with his own pet peeve, as is the case with George Christensen, John “Wacka” Williams, Andrew Broad or Barry O’Sullivan and the other part-time dissidents in the Nationals party room. He is mainstream Nationals heartland – a leader in his own state and one who demands attention across its borders.

And at a time when the Nats are feeling their oats, as it were, this can spell trouble. Cormann, ever zealous to guard the prime minister’s constantly turned back, says not to worry; as Barnaby Joyce rejoins the federal team stability will be restored.

But this may be wishful thinking. Even during his temporary exile in his New England electorate, Joyce mused that the incipient revolt over the banking inquiry might not be such a bad idea. He knows, better than anyone, that his troops want more independence, more clout – and, it follows, less Turnbull.

It is highly likely they will demand bigger and more frequent concessions from his wafer-thin government, and an actual split from the Coalition is not out of the question. Of course, the Nats would guarantee confidence and supply – they do not want to wreck the place altogether, at least when there is still a chance they can retain the perks of office.

But they could well make government effectively unworkable, which would have much the same effect. And in doing so they could force the Libs to make a choice: Turnbull or the bush. Given that there are quite a few Libs who would welcome their current leader’s demise, the risks are very real.

So far, Turnbull has held the line at least because there is no consensus for an alternative, but the Nats are ready to fill that gap: they are deeply suspicious of Scott Morrison and regard Bishop as beyond the pale; but Peter Dutton, a hardline conservative and a Queenslander, is regarded as an ally.

Dutton may be unpopular with the electorate, but so is Turnbull – for the marginal Nats, the change could hardly be worse and just may be better, at least in holding their own seats. Barilaro, formerly a councillor in Queanbeyan, seems an unlikely revolutionary, but weird times turn up weird warriors. Yet another worry for Turnbull before he tucks into the Point Piper Christmas pudding.

Mungo MacCallum

Mungo MacCallum is a political journalist and commentator. His books include Run Johnny Run, Poll Dancing, and Punch and Judy. Visit his blog, The View from Billinudgel.

Read on

Image from ‘Camping’

Unhappy ‘Camping’

Lena Dunham’s new comedy series is an accidental portrait of toxic femininity

Image from ‘Russian Doll’

A bug in the code: ‘Russian Doll’

This existential comedy is 2019’s first must-see Netflix series

Image of crossbenchers Derryn Hinch, Adam Bandt, Nick McKim, Kerryn Phelps, Tim Storer and Andrew Wilkie discussing the medical transfer bill in November

Debate over asylum seeker medical transfers reaches new lows

The government’s scare campaign against the crossbench bill denigrates doctors and detainees

Image from ‘Capharnaüm’

‘Capharnaüm’: giving voice to the voiceless

Nadine Labaki on what motivated her exploration of turmoil’s impact on children