Australian politics, society & culture

Tuesday, 2nd September 2014


We usually try to avoid taking unambiguous positions in PoliticOz editorials. There are generally at least two legitimate sides to every story. But if there are two positions on the Abbott government's energy policy, only one of them aligns with the public interest. The other is rent-seeking of the first order.

The Coalition has consistently misrepresented the cost to energy consumers of the carbon pricing scheme and the renewable energy target (RET). It has asserted that these regulations, intended to transition Australia's economy toward a low-carbon future, are the main reason power bills have doubled over the past five years. But that's just not true. The real driver of power bill increases is another regulatory framework, one which provides an incentive for network companies (whose profits are tied to the fortunes of coal-fired power) to charge power consumers for the unnecessary "gold-plating" of grid infrastructure. Because its companies never invested in the renewables sector, the coal industry is now effectively in competition with the renewables industry. Abbott appointed noted climate-change skeptic Dick Warburton to head a largely unnecessary (because one had already been done) review into the RET. Warburton's report concludes that the RET represents regulatory failure because it does what it was designed to do – namely, drive business away from coal-fired power and toward renewables – and that this is somehow unfair. It's a conclusion that only makes sense from within the coal industry.

All this amounts to aggressive support for the incumbent coal industry, which earns profits by externalising most of its environmental and public health costs. The Warburton review also concludes that the renewables industry should get by without regulatory support, though that ignores the enormous subsidies which go toward coal power generation in the form of tax breaks and "compensation". Fascinatingly, as Peter Martin points out in The Age, the carbon-reduction scheme which would best satisfy the Warburton review's concerns about cost is none other than (wait for it) an emissions trading scheme based on a floating carbon price, which was to be Australia's policy next year before the government "axed the tax".

Russell Marks
Politicoz Editor

Sign up to get Politicoz delivered
to your email address every weekday at lunch time.

Australia’s Iraqi ambassador warns on weapons supply to Kurds

"Iraq’s ambassador to Australia has called for any weapons intended for delivery to Kurdish fighters to be provided via the central government in Baghdad." (Daniel Hurst, The Guardian)

Also: Australia edging closer to war in Iraq (Mark Kenny and David Wroe, Fairfax)

Comment and analysis: Mark Kenny on parliament's role (Fairfax); Paul McGeough on risks (Fairfax); Hugh White on intelligence (Fairfax); Stuart Rollo on the US's contradictory interests (The Drum)

Treasurer would get power to delay super increases under latest mining tax repeal legislation

"In its fresh attempt to axe the mining tax the government has introduced another version of its repeal laws to parliament, with a new clause which would give the treasurer the power to delay increases to superannuation." (Emma Griffiths, ABC News)

Also: One-stop shop for environmental approvals in the senate (Sid Maher, The Australian, possible paywall)

Royal Commission says insulation deaths were fault of the government’s program

"The deaths of four installers participating in the Rudd government’s home insulation program would not have occurred if the scheme had been properly designed and implemented, a royal commission has found." (Michelle Grattan, The Conversation)

Also: Family firms hit by home insulation fallout ready to seek compensation (Sarah Elks, The Australian, possible paywall)

Business fights ACCC rule on "effects test"

"Executives from Qantas Airways, Caltex, Foxtel, Woolworths, and Wesfarmers are protesting a push from competition regulators with support from Small Business Minister Bruce Billson to introduce an “effect test” to pursue market leaders that attempt to exclude smaller players." (Fleur Anderson, Australian Financial Review)

Premiers Jay Weatherill and Campbell Newman unite to push recognition plebiscite

"SA Premier Jay Weatherill has written to Queensland Premier Campbell Newman to request that a referendum to acknowledge Indigenous Australians is a priority item for the Council for the Australian Federation. Mr Newman has agreed to the request." (Patricia Karvelas, The Australian)