Australian politics, society & culture

Friday, 22nd August 2014


Bill Shorten's decision to yesterday name himself publicly as the focus of an historic rape investigation says something about the way politics and the media work now. The formal investigation has concluded, with Victoria Police and the Office of Public Prosecutions both agreeing that Shorten has no case to answer after an unnamed complainant made allegations some months ago. Shorten obviously hopes that's the end of the matter, and Malcolm Turnbull, Tony Abbott and Tanya Plibersek – who is very active on improving the political climate to encourage greater female participation – agree.

That Shorten outed himself at all is testament to the power of social media. It was known in Canberra circles that Shorten was the subject of the complaint, but the Canberra rumour mill is rife with all kinds of material which, traditionally, rarely makes it into mainstream news. It's not difficult to imagine a scenario whereby innuendo and rumour persists on blogs for months, building to a tsunami of sentiment which forces Shorten into an untenable political position. Talkback radio may have whipped up a frenzied opposition to Julia Gillard, for instance, but the vilest elements of that campaign were generated and sustained on the net.

As Plibersek says, nobody has any power to control what happens on the blogs. Shorten's political opponents have an obvious incentive to keep the talk going, and the decision by the Herald Sun to run the story under a front-page denial headline ("I didn't do it") will no doubt be read into in all sorts of ways. Despite Shorten's attempt to deny the rumour mill oxygen, it's possible that an alternative interpretation – one which sees the political class closing around one of its own against an outsider, a woman who is now being marginalised by the male-dominated power centre – may yet gain traction. There is, after all, an overlapping narrative here, a victims' tragedy about the near-impossibility of recording convictions in historical sexual assault cases.

Russell Marks
Politicoz Editor

Sign up to get Politicoz delivered
to your email address every weekday at lunch time.

Budget sales job ‘unfortunate’, Treasury says

"Treasury secretary Martin Parkinson has conceded the federal government’s marooned budget strategy should have canvassed tax reform to counter complaints over its claimed unfairness." (Jacob Greber, Australian Financial Review)

Also: Tony Abbott says budget is ‘not draconian, it's necessary’ (James Massola, Fairfax)

Comments: Short-sightedness on tax reform will stifle Australia (Callam Pickering, Business Spectator); The government needs to make the moral case (Maxine Montaigne, The Drum)

Child abuse victim support groups outraged over Cardinal George Pell's testimony

"Cardinal Pell appeared at the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse via videolink from the Vatican." (Thomas Oriti, ABC News)

Protesters tear down fence at Tony Abbott speech event in Adelaide

"Dozens of police officers, including 10 mounted police, contained protesters after a security fence was broken down amid chants including ‘Tory scum’ and ‘Get those animals off those horses’." (AAP)

Also: Evidence-free beliefs: history in the hands of the Coalition (Tony Taylor, The Conversation)

UN agency in High Court challenge to Abbott government's treatment of asylum seekers

"The United Nations refugee agency will seek to appear in a High Court challenge to the Abbott government's power to intercept boats on the highs seas, hold asylum seekers indefinitely on customs vessels and seek to return them to third countries." (Michael Gordon, The Age)

Also: Scott Morrison faces questions at children in detention inquiry – live updates (Daniel Hurst, The Guardian)

Comment: Morrison's only option is to release all children in detention (Karen Zwi, Fairfax)

Abbott: Risk of terror executions on home soil

"Tony Abbott has warned that attacks such as the beheading of American journalist James Foley could happen on Australian soil without constant vigilance, because of the extremist threat posed by Islamic State terrorists." (Stefanie Balogh, The Australian)

Also: Christian and Jewish leaders campaign to support Muslim community (Gabrielle Chan, The Guardian); Pentagon: Isis is 'beyond anything we've seen' and must be contained (Spencer Ackerman, The Guardian)

Comment: Abbott scratches his itchy trigger finger (Barrie Cassidy, The Drum)