Australian politics, society & culture

Thursday, 21st August 2014


Yesterday's horrific video of the apparent beheading of US journalist James Foley by what appears to be a British recruit to the Islamic State (formerly ISIL or ISIS) brings into sharp relief the domestic debate about new counter-terrorism laws. The Abbott government is set to introduce the bills when parliament resumes next week. Among other measures, the government proposes to criminalise the act of travelling "to a designated area where terrorist organisations are conducting hostile activities unless there is a legitimate purpose". Civil libertarians are particularly concerned that the government also wants to reverse the onus of proof, so that a person returning from such a "designated area" would be assumed to have participated in terrorist activities unless he or she can prove otherwise. The Labor opposition shares these concerns.

The Abbott government says its proposed laws are necessary to deal with the 150 Australians who are believed to have provided assistance to the Islamic State, which has captured large areas of northwestern Iraq and northeastern Syria in advance of its goal to establish a caliphate across the Middle East. The Islamic State has claimed responsibility for Foley's murder and threatens more if the United States doesn't cease its military action. David Cameron's government in Britain is also trying to prevent its citizens from travelling to fight in Iraq and Syria, but against Cameron's relative call for calm –  he warned against any "knee-jerk reaction" – Abbott's language is inflammatory. He has explicitly called on Muslims to join "team Australia" and declared that "you don't migrate to this country unless you want to join our team". As Race Discrimination Commissioner Tim Soutphommasane points out, such language risks conflating the problem of Islamic extremism with Muslim immigration generally – a conflation that's been well and truly made by commentators on the extreme right, who are presenting Muslim leaders' criticism of the proposed legislation in terms of a culture war. The political art of balancing public safety with the protection of civil liberties is a difficult one, and is unlikely to be helped by framing the issue in such terms.

*Today's image, which shows the Islamic State's territory as of 16 August 2014, is a modified version of the graphic provided under Creative Commons license.

Russell Marks
Politicoz Editor

Sign up to get Politicoz delivered
to your email address every weekday at lunch time.

GP co-payment: Doctors reject current proposal, AMA waits on response to alternative plan

"The AMA, which will today make details of its proposal public, says it is concerned about vulnerable groups, including those in aged care, the chronically ill, unemployed, people with disabilities, those in remote areas and children." (Sophie Scott and Alison Branley, ABC News)

Also: AMA's plan must not be self-serving, expert warns (Daniel Hurst, The Guardian); Medibank scheme may lead to US-style ‘disaster’ (Harriet Alexander, Fairfax)

Labor could block key elements of counter-terrorism package

"Labor could block key elements of the government’s counter-terrorism package, including the reversal of the onus of proof, expanding intelligence collection of metadata and tough penalties for people who disclose information on special intelligence operations." (Gabrielle Chan, The Guardian)

Also: Muslim leaders reject Tony Abbott's proposed new terrorism laws (Saffron Howden and Rachel Olding, Fairfax); What does ‘Team Australia’ mean? (Michelle Grattan, The Conversation)

Statistics: Team Australia: the reality of the figures (Jonathan Green, The Drum)

Crossbench takes treasurer to task

"The federal government has been taken to task by key crossbench senators for a confused budget sales job, as Prime Minister Tony Abbott signalled a compromise deal on the $7 GP co-payment could be in the offing to ease the burden on pensioners." (James Massola and Lisa Cox, Fairfax)

Also: RBA tells Abbott to hold nerve (Phillip Coorey, Australian Financial Review)

Comment: Why poor people don't matter to Abbott and Hockey (Ross Gittins, Sydney Morning Herald)

Asylum staff hit by mental health crisis

"The mental health crisis inside the detention centre on Christmas Island is now taking its toll on those who guard the asylum seekers, with one female employee attempting to take her life and a male considered at serious risk of self-harm." (Michael Gordon and Sarah Whyte, Fairfax)

Also: Scott Morrison's Syrian returns ‘partner’ distances itself from repatriation efforts (Lenore Taylor and Oliver Laughland, The Guardian); High Court challenge to 157 Tamil asylum seeker case to proceed (ABC News)

Comment: We wouldn't need whistleblowers' bravery if Morrison did his job properly (Elizabeth O'Shea, The Guardian)

News Corp Australia leaked accounts show 1,000 jobs cut across mastheads

"The Australian’s revenues dropped 20% from $135m to $108m in 2012-13 and the masthead’s operating loss fell to $30m." (Amanda Meade, The Guardian, reporting on figures published by Crikey)