Newsletter

Print

WORLD

'Mao: The Unknown Story' by Jung Chang & Jon Halliday

The Monthly | Noted | July 2005 | Add a Comment

In a 1970 interview with a favoured apologist, Mao Tse-Tung described himself in Chinese as literally “a man without law or limit”. This self-assessment was rendered in English as “a lone monk”. Similarly sympathetic mistranslation of his motives and methods have helped preserve The Great Helmsman’s reputation. “Oh yes, bit of a tyrant, I suppose. But nothing compared to Halliburton.”

Jung Chang and Jon Halliday will have none of that. Their account begins on the day of Mao’s birth, ends on the day of his death and wastes nary a word between, reinstating historical omissions like Mao’s disastrous generalship at Tucheng, demolishing myths like the Dadu Bridge Crossing and depicting the Long March as, at least for its instigator, the Gentle Constitutional. To Mao’s crimes, they apply an arresting calculus. The siege of Changchun, for instance, was bloodier than the rape of Nanjing; the resources ploughed into the Chinese bomb cost more lives than the incineration of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. All that can be said in his defence as a politician is that he kept promises. “We believe in dialectics, and so we can’t not be in favour of death,” he stated at the Party Congress inaugurating the Great Leap Forward, with its toll of 38 million.

Mao’s shortcoming is that its sourcing, while exhaustive, is undifferentiated. Documented fact, memoir, interview, rumour, conjecture – all co-exist in uneasy equality. And Mao, while we learn that he was addicted to sleeping pills and obsessed with his bowels, remains even at the end – dare one say it? – somewhat inscrutable. But Chung and Halliday have, at least for the moment, pushed Mao to the top of the tyrant charts. With a bullet.
 
Print
Read the latest MONTHLY with a subscription — SUBSCRIBE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Twitter
@THEMONTHLY @SLOWTV

Now free online – Robert Manne's essay on @TurnbullMalcolm from our April issue: http://t.co/vrCExhRy #auspol
Wednesday, 23 May 2012 - 7:30pm
Robert Manne's cover essay on @TurnbullMalcolm from our April issue is now free online in full: http://t.co/vrCExhRy #auspol
Wednesday, 23 May 2012 - 5:30pm
Today's Shortlist: http://t.co/101spggC @TheMonthly
Wednesday, 23 May 2012 - 3:35pm
The April cover story on @TurnbullMalcolm by Robert Manne is now free online in full (fixed link): http://t.co/vrCExhRy #auspol
Wednesday, 23 May 2012 - 2:11pm
twitter
 

Site Highlights



POLITICS
Human Rights (200)
Australian Politics (119)
Feminism (98)
Racism (94)
Robert Manne (71)
Obama (60)
Islam (60)
American Politics (58)
Censorship (48)
Multiculturalism (39)
Consumerism (36)
Pokies (30)
Stolen Generations (28)
Childcare (28)
Freedom of Speech (26)
Prime Ministers (22)
Political Parties (19)
History of Australia (19)
Social Justice (18)
Liberalism (18)
Gay Marriage (18)
Germaine Greer (17)
Waleed Aly (17)
Kitsch (16)
Indigenous Rights (16)
SOCIETY
Australian History (112)
Travel (99)
Ethics (69)
Neuroscience (66)
Asylum Seekers (56)
Lawyers (52)
Gender (52)
Anthropology (46)
Capitalism (46)
Sexuality (45)
Aboriginal People (42)
Facebook (36)
Australian Society (32)
Scholars (30)
Homosexuality (30)
Neuropsychology (26)
Muslim (26)
Historians (24)
Health (24)
Clive Hamilton (23)
Sociology (23)
Gambling (23)
Decision-making (22)
Alice Springs (21)
Parenting (19)
State Library of Victoria (18)
Climate change denialism (17)
Conservatism (17)
AFL (16)
CULTURE
Literature (152)
Fiction (146)
Hollywood (112)
Photography (112)
Memoir (108)
Arts (94)
Biography (88)
Painting (84)
Comedy (63)
Musicians (58)
Dance (54)
Philosophy (50)
Architecture (48)
Short Stories (31)
Art (25)
Cooking (24)
Autobiography (24)
20 Australian Masterpieces (22)
Jazz (21)
Modern Masterpieces (20)
Film (20)
Top 20 Arts Masterpieces (20)
Arts Masterpieces (20)
Aussie Masterpieces (20)
Australian Film (19)
Directors (16)
WORLD
China (213)
Iraq (115)
Afghanistan (70)
India (69)
Ireland (68)
Britain (60)
World economy (60)
Middle East (55)
Asia (54)
Africa (54)
Barack Obama (52)
New York City (50)
Egypt (45)
New Zealand (44)
Pakistan (44)
World War II (42)
Foreign Policy (42)
Russia (42)
New York Times (37)
Indonesia (37)
Iran (37)
Eurozone (37)
Italy (36)
George W Bush (34)
European Union (34)
Japan (33)
Terrorism (32)
Greece (28)
United Nations (28)
East Timor (26)
Taliban (25)
Libya (25)
Arab Spring (24)
Israel (23)
Communism (22)
Egyptian revolution (22)
Beijing (19)
Syria (19)
American Military (18)
Thailand (17)
News International (17)
Russian politics (17)
Saudi Arabia (16)
Nuclear power (16)
Libyan uprising (16)
Peak oil (16)
ENVIRONMENT
Climate Change (275)
Nuclear (146)
Drought (78)
Global Warming (58)
Sustainability (46)
Tasmania (44)
ETS (28)
Carbon dioxide (26)
Amazon (24)
Conservation (24)
Rainforest (20)
Emissions trading (20)
Carbon tax (17)
Carbon emissions (17)
Nuclear Energy (16)
Floods (16)
Ecology (16)
Water crisis (16)
ECONOMICS
Business (154)
Australian Economy (78)
The Global Financial Crisis (68)
European debt (55)
Finance (40)
Wall Street (39)
Global Financial Crisis (37)
Globalisation (37)
Global finance (36)
Recession (27)
Unemployment (20)
Food Production (20)
Population growth (17)
Stock Market (16)
MEDIA
ABC (108)
Journalism (94)
Australian Media (57)
Rupert Murdoch (55)
Radio National (41)
Quarterly Essay (40)
News Corporation (36)
Fairfax (35)
Google (33)
Wikileaks (28)
News Limited (26)
Social Media (25)
Twitter (25)
Communications (23)
Guardian (23)
Assange (23)
Phone-hacking scandal (22)
Julian Assange (19)
The Australian newspaper (18)
Crikey (17)
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Drugs (64)
Psychology (46)
Evolution (33)
Biology (28)
Disease (22)
Genetics (21)
Flu (17)