Newsletter

Print

WORLD

Robert Menzies & Winston Churchill

The Monthly | Encounters | April 2007 | Add a Comment

Words: Shane Maloney | Illustration: Chris Grosz

Robert Menzies' first trip to England was a profoundly emotional experience. At 41, Jeparit-born Bob had finally come "home". It was 1935, the Silver Jubilee of George V, and pilgrims from the Empire were converging on London for the pomp and circumstance.

For Menzies, it was a happy convergence for a number of reasons. As the attorney-general and a member of Prime Minister Joe Lyons' entourage, he could contribute to negotiations with British trade officials. And as a barrister in private practice, he could appear for a client, Paper Sacks Pty Ltd, in its appeal to the Privy Council.

But above all, the Anglophile colonial could drink deep from the nurturing fount of English tradition and culture. There were silk knee breeches and cocked hats to be worn, Buckingham Palace and Gray's Inn to be visited. In the green and pleasant landscape, Ming discovered "the secret springs of English poetry". One Saturday afternoon in Kent, he paid a call on Winston Churchill.

For Churchill, these were the wilderness years. Past 60, politically isolated and living beyond his means, he was at his nadir. When not thundering in the House of Commons against Indian self-rule, he retreated to his country house, Chartwell, to write, paint and indulge in a little light bricklaying.

Menzies was received courteously by Mrs Churchill. Winston was in the swimming pool, Clementine explained. "It was a splendid sight," Menzies recalled in his memoir, Afternoon Light. The pool was large, circular and heated, and sited on a grassy slope with panoramic views. In the middle was "a jutting form rather reminiscent of the Rock of Gibraltar". The rock stirred, removed the cotton wool from its ears and waded ashore.

Tea was served and Bob listened, unimpressed, while Churchill banged on about the menace of Hitler. His host was a remarkable man, Menzies concluded, but he had a one-track mind and lacked discipline. This opinion was reinforced shortly after, when he observed Churchill in the House of Commons. "Feet of clay", he recorded in his diary.

Six years later, now the prime minister of Australia, Menzies was back in England. In response to Menzies' warnings about Japan, Churchill, now the prime minister of Great Britain, offered nothing but "blood, toil, tears and sweat".

For all his imperial rhetoric, Winnie had little interest in the Dominions, much less the views of their politicians. His opinion of Menzies is nowhere recorded. But in one sense at least, Bob was his enthusiastic follower. On Sir Winston's death, Sir Robert succeeded him as the Lord Warden of the Cinque Ports.

 
Print
Read the latest MONTHLY with a subscription — SUBSCRIBE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Twitter
@THEMONTHLY @SLOWTV

The politically disengaged in this country will more and more rely on a limited number of politically biased sources: http://t.co/6kUu7tCE
Wednesday, 8 February 2012 - 8:34pm
There is no way at present of preventing the penetration of mainstream media by those, like Gina Rinehart: http://t.co/6kUu7tCE #Auspol
Wednesday, 8 February 2012 - 8:28pm
Lord Monckton and the Future of Australian Media | Robert Manne: http://t.co/5rCpNM0d via #Auspol via @THEMONTHLY
Wednesday, 8 February 2012 - 8:23pm
More amazing robots, this time folding socks, amongst other things: http://t.co/T4RAka7P
Wednesday, 8 February 2012 - 4:54pm
twitter
 

Site Highlights



POLITICS
Human Rights (186)
Racism (92)
Australian Politics (88)
Feminism (88)
Robert Manne (67)
Obama (56)
Islam (52)
American Politics (47)
Censorship (44)
Multiculturalism (39)
Consumerism (36)
Pokies (30)
Stolen Generations (28)
Childcare (26)
Freedom of Speech (26)
Prime Ministers (20)
Political Parties (19)
Liberalism (18)
Social Justice (18)
History of Australia (18)
Germaine Greer (17)
Waleed Aly (17)
Gay Marriage (16)
SOCIETY
Australian History (108)
Travel (98)
Ethics (68)
Asylum Seekers (56)
Lawyers (52)
Gender (51)
Neuroscience (50)
Anthropology (45)
Capitalism (45)
Sexuality (45)
Aboriginal People (41)
Facebook (30)
Australian Society (30)
Scholars (29)
Homosexuality (24)
Muslim (23)
Clive Hamilton (23)
Decision-making (22)
Sociology (22)
Alice Springs (21)
Gambling (20)
Historians (20)
State Library of Victoria (18)
Neuropsychology (16)
CULTURE
Theatre (160)
Literature (145)
Fiction (138)
Hollywood (108)
Memoir (106)
Arts (87)
Biography (86)
Photography (80)
Painting (79)
Humour (77)
Library (64)
Comedy (58)
Musicians (56)
Opera (53)
Football (50)
Dance (47)
Architecture (38)
Short Stories (30)
Autobiography (24)
20 Australian Masterpieces (22)
Cooking (21)
Modern Masterpieces (20)
Aussie Masterpieces (20)
Top 20 Arts Masterpieces (20)
Arts Masterpieces (20)
Art (19)
Australian Film (19)
Jazz (18)
Philosophy (17)
Directors (16)
WORLD
China (199)
Iraq (114)
India (64)
Ireland (62)
Afghanistan (60)
World economy (60)
England (58)
Britain (54)
Middle East (54)
France (53)
Asia (51)
New York City (50)
Africa (46)
Barack Obama (46)
New Zealand (42)
Egypt (41)
Foreign Policy (41)
Pakistan (39)
World War II (38)
Germany (37)
New York Times (36)
George W Bush (34)
Indonesia (34)
Italy (34)
Russia (33)
Eurozone (31)
Iran (29)
Terrorism (29)
European Union (28)
California (27)
Aid (26)
United Nations (26)
East Timor (24)
Taliban (23)
Israel (22)
Communism (22)
Libya (22)
Egyptian revolution (21)
Beijing (19)
American Military (16)
Thailand (16)
Nuclear power (16)
Greece (16)
Libyan uprising (16)
ENVIRONMENT
Climate Change (265)
Nuclear (142)
Energy (116)
Drought (76)
Global Warming (57)
Sustainability (46)
Tasmania (43)
Dogs (42)
ETS (26)
Amazon (24)
Carbon dioxide (24)
Conservation (22)
Rainforest (20)
Emissions trading (20)
Carbon tax (17)
Water crisis (16)
Carbon emissions (16)
Nuclear Energy (16)
Ecology (16)
Horses (16)
ECONOMICS
Business (152)
Australian Economy (77)
The Global Financial Crisis (66)
European debt (41)
Wall Street (39)
Finance (38)
Globalisation (37)
Global Financial Crisis (34)
Global finance (32)
Recession (26)
Unemployment (20)
Food Production (18)
Stock Market (16)
Population growth (16)
MEDIA
ABC (102)
Journalism (87)
Australian Media (54)
Rupert Murdoch (46)
Radio National (40)
Quarterly Essay (37)
Fairfax (33)
News Corporation (31)
Google (29)
Wikileaks (27)
Social Media (25)
News Limited (24)
Communications (23)
Twitter (23)
Assange (22)
Guardian (21)
Phone-hacking scandal (21)
Julian Assange (18)
Crikey (16)
The Australian newspaper (16)
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Brain (71)
Drugs (56)
Psychology (41)
Evolution (32)
Biology (27)
Genetics (21)
Disease (19)
Flu (17)