Newsletter

Print

ENVIRONMENT

Malcolm Fraser & Galarrwuy Yunupingu

The Monthly | Encounters | March 2006 | Add a Comment

Words: Shane Maloney | Illustration: Chris Grosz

Both were princes in their own lands.

One was a scion of the squattocracy, the only son of a wealthy grazier and the grandson of a conservative politician, educated at Melbourne Grammar and Oxford University and sent to parliament at 25. Patrician in bearing and speech, he was now 48 and Prime Minister of Australia.

The other was one of the many children of Munggurawuy of the Gumatj clan of the Yolnu people of Yirkalla. Raised among his siblings, then sent to Bible college in Brisbane, he was skilled in painting, dancing, acting and music. At 30 he was a seasoned interpreter and negotiator who represented 81 Aboriginal communities as the elected Chairman of the Northern Land Council.

The year was 1978 and the two men faced each other across a divide that went to the heart of their respective views of the world. For Galarrwuy Yunupingu, it was the survival of his country. For Malcolm Fraser, it was the economic development of the nation. The issue was approval of the Ranger uranium mine in Kakadu. At stake was the future of land rights legislation.

With negotiations at an impasse, Yunupingu proposed a fishing trip. Fraser, a keen angler, rose to the bait.

The place was a mangrove-fringed billabong where the creeks that flow from the Arhnem Land escarpment feed the headwaters of the South Alligator River. Mt Brockman, the site of the proposed mine, was just a few kilometres away. ”I deliberately took him there so I could ask him on the spot: how could mining take place in a national park?“ As they cast their lures, Yunupingu put his question.

The barramundi were biting, but Fraser wasn’t. ”It was an enjoyable occasion,” he recalls. ”I didn’t feel put upon.”

The PM caught ten or so nice big ones – “enough for the pot” – and there was fishing talk over dinner later in Darwin. But it was clear to Yunupingu that mining would proceed whether the Aborigines agreed or not. Later that year, under ruthless pressure from the federal government, he signed the deal.

In the years that followed, Malcolm Fraser was spurned by his own tribe and condemned to preach in the wilderness. Galarrwuy Yunupingu continues to fish in the lands of his ancestors, a perennial media target. At the Ranger mine, more than 120 incidents, spills and leaks have been reported. And as the spot price for uranium reaches a new high, the timetable for ore processing has been extended.

 
Print
Read the latest MONTHLY with a subscription — SUBSCRIBE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Twitter
@THEMONTHLY @SLOWTV

"America is broke and angry, and thinks the government is to blame." – Julia Baird on #Romney and the #Republicans: http://t.co/FVCV4aHt
Thursday, 9 February 2012 - 11:36am
"Fox News offers to its audience an alternative version of reality" – Robert Manne on #Monckton & #Rinehart: http://t.co/IiP0Tujd #climate
Thursday, 9 February 2012 - 10:18am
Yep, that'll work.RT @nytjim: A day after Sky News clampdown, BBC tells journalists not to break news first on Twitter. http://t.co/1Qkhyo7E
Thursday, 9 February 2012 - 9:47am
The politically disengaged in this country will more and more rely on a limited number of politically biased sources: http://t.co/6kUu7tCE
Wednesday, 8 February 2012 - 8:34pm
twitter
 

Site Highlights



POLITICS
Human Rights (186)
Racism (92)
Australian Politics (88)
Feminism (88)
Robert Manne (67)
Obama (56)
Islam (52)
American Politics (47)
Censorship (44)
Multiculturalism (39)
Consumerism (36)
Pokies (30)
Stolen Generations (28)
Childcare (26)
Freedom of Speech (26)
Prime Ministers (20)
Political Parties (19)
Liberalism (18)
Social Justice (18)
History of Australia (18)
Germaine Greer (17)
Waleed Aly (17)
Gay Marriage (16)
SOCIETY
Australian History (108)
Travel (98)
Ethics (68)
Asylum Seekers (56)
Lawyers (52)
Gender (51)
Neuroscience (50)
Anthropology (45)
Capitalism (45)
Sexuality (45)
Aboriginal People (41)
Facebook (30)
Australian Society (30)
Scholars (29)
Homosexuality (24)
Muslim (23)
Clive Hamilton (23)
Decision-making (22)
Sociology (22)
Alice Springs (21)
Gambling (20)
Historians (20)
State Library of Victoria (18)
Neuropsychology (16)
CULTURE
Theatre (160)
Literature (145)
Fiction (138)
Hollywood (108)
Memoir (106)
Arts (87)
Biography (86)
Photography (80)
Painting (79)
Humour (77)
Library (64)
Comedy (58)
Musicians (56)
Opera (53)
Football (50)
Dance (47)
Architecture (38)
Short Stories (30)
Autobiography (24)
20 Australian Masterpieces (22)
Cooking (21)
Modern Masterpieces (20)
Aussie Masterpieces (20)
Top 20 Arts Masterpieces (20)
Arts Masterpieces (20)
Art (19)
Australian Film (19)
Jazz (18)
Philosophy (17)
Directors (16)
WORLD
China (199)
Iraq (114)
India (64)
Ireland (62)
Afghanistan (60)
World economy (60)
England (58)
Britain (54)
Middle East (54)
France (53)
Asia (51)
New York City (50)
Africa (46)
Barack Obama (46)
New Zealand (42)
Egypt (41)
Foreign Policy (41)
Pakistan (39)
World War II (38)
Germany (37)
New York Times (36)
George W Bush (34)
Indonesia (34)
Italy (34)
Russia (33)
Eurozone (31)
Iran (29)
Terrorism (29)
European Union (28)
California (27)
Aid (26)
United Nations (26)
East Timor (24)
Taliban (23)
Israel (22)
Communism (22)
Libya (22)
Egyptian revolution (21)
Beijing (19)
American Military (16)
Thailand (16)
Nuclear power (16)
Greece (16)
Libyan uprising (16)
ENVIRONMENT
Climate Change (265)
Nuclear (142)
Energy (116)
Drought (76)
Global Warming (57)
Sustainability (46)
Tasmania (43)
Dogs (42)
ETS (26)
Amazon (24)
Carbon dioxide (24)
Conservation (22)
Rainforest (20)
Emissions trading (20)
Carbon tax (17)
Water crisis (16)
Carbon emissions (16)
Nuclear Energy (16)
Ecology (16)
Horses (16)
ECONOMICS
Business (152)
Australian Economy (77)
The Global Financial Crisis (66)
European debt (41)
Wall Street (39)
Finance (38)
Globalisation (37)
Global Financial Crisis (34)
Global finance (32)
Recession (26)
Unemployment (20)
Food Production (18)
Stock Market (16)
Population growth (16)
MEDIA
ABC (102)
Journalism (87)
Australian Media (54)
Rupert Murdoch (46)
Radio National (40)
Quarterly Essay (37)
Fairfax (33)
News Corporation (31)
Google (29)
Wikileaks (27)
Social Media (25)
News Limited (24)
Communications (23)
Twitter (23)
Assange (22)
Guardian (21)
Phone-hacking scandal (21)
Julian Assange (18)
Crikey (16)
The Australian newspaper (16)
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Brain (71)
Drugs (56)
Psychology (41)
Evolution (32)
Biology (27)
Genetics (21)
Disease (19)
Flu (17)