Newsletter

Print

SOCIETY

'Claude Lévi-Strauss: The Poet in the Laboratory' By Patrick Wilcken

The Monthly | Noted | April 2011 | Add a Comment

'Claude Lévi-Strauss: The Poet in the Laboratory', By Patrick Wilcken, Bloomsbury, 384pp; $59.99

In 1938 an obscure French anthropologist, sporting a topee and with a monkey clinging to his boot, led an expedition into deepest Brazil. Part scientific enterprise, part youthful lighting out for the territory, its fieldwork was patchy, impressionistic and largely outdated. But it brought Claude Lévi-Strauss into contact with indigenous people, producing a revolution that spread into every branch of the humanities.

No one has mythologised that ramshackle Brazilian jaunt more brilliantly than Lévi-Strauss himself in Tristes Tropiques (1955). In the first English-language life of this key twentieth-century thinker, Sydney-born Patrick Wilcken rightly accords equal weight to Lévi-Strauss’s North American sojourn, arguing that it was just as crucial to his intellectual development.

Lévi-Strauss spent the war in New York, one of the thousands of European academics and artists who had fled Nazism. The Surrealists grouped around André Breton encouraged his interest in indigenous artefacts and myths, which they valued over an exhausted western tradition. The decisive influence, however, was Roman Jakobson, who introduced Lévi-Strauss to structural linguistics. This emphasised the formal systems of language over the amassing of descriptive data and led, in the postwar era, to the central precept in Lévi-Strauss’s work: that a hidden, pan-human pattern structures all culture. Structuralism, as it came to be known, placed anthropology at the forefront of radical scholarship and Lévi-Strauss at the centre of French intellectual life for the next 20 years.

In an age when a university could offer a chair in the “religions of uncivilised peoples”, Lévi-Strauss insisted on the sophistication of low-tech societies. Young intellectuals, Roland Barthes and Michel Foucault among them, were drawn to ideas that seemed to break with Eurocentric models. Structuralist principles, such as the organisation of thought around binary oppositions – the raw and the cooked, say – were applied to everything from psychoanalysis to the study of fashion. Humanities scholars, always a little queasy about the ‘soft’ basis of their claims to knowledge, embraced a methodology that promised objectivity and rigour – science, in a word.

Calmly even-handed, Wilcken argues that the holy grail of scientific absolutism lured Lévi-Strauss into increasingly grandiose claims. What had been audacious grew arcane. Anglo-American anthropologists seized on Lévi-Strauss’s disinclination for fieldwork to discredit his conclusions. In France, the famous events of May 1968 showed that history, downplayed by Lévi-Strauss in favour of myth, had never gone away. The rise of the post-isms isolated him still further. Well before he died in October 2009, structuralism looked like a movement of one. Lévi-Strauss was its pioneer, high priest and, finally, its sole disciple.

When asked about his personal life, Lévi-Strauss “closed the door”. Consequently, this landmark biography misses being a memorable one. It opens dramatically, its human subject centre stage and illuminated, but grows repetitive as Wilcken falls back on summaries of ideas. We are left with a ghost. In a spooky doubling, The Poet in the Laboratory repeats Lévi-Strauss’s slide from liveliness to abstraction.

 
Print
Read the latest MONTHLY with a subscription — SUBSCRIBE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Twitter
@THEMONTHLY @SLOWTV

Egypt: no revolution for women, who make up just 2% of a hostile new parliament - http://t.co/n2SMI9Uy
Tuesday, 22 May 2012 - 3:49pm
Tuesday, 22 May 2012 - 3:46pm
Today's Shortlist: http://t.co/FwgzBNUG @TheMonthly
Tuesday, 22 May 2012 - 3:44pm
New @SlowTV video – Janette Turner Hospital on writing and teaching literature: http://t.co/VrH6OPO8
Tuesday, 22 May 2012 - 12:15pm
twitter
 

Site Highlights



POLITICS
Human Rights (200)
Australian Politics (119)
Feminism (98)
Racism (94)
Robert Manne (71)
Obama (60)
Islam (60)
American Politics (58)
Censorship (48)
Multiculturalism (39)
Consumerism (36)
Pokies (30)
Childcare (28)
Stolen Generations (28)
Freedom of Speech (26)
Prime Ministers (22)
History of Australia (19)
Political Parties (19)
Social Justice (18)
Liberalism (18)
Gay Marriage (18)
Waleed Aly (17)
Germaine Greer (17)
Kitsch (16)
Indigenous Rights (16)
SOCIETY
Australian History (112)
Travel (99)
Ethics (69)
Neuroscience (66)
Asylum Seekers (56)
Lawyers (52)
Gender (52)
Capitalism (46)
Anthropology (46)
Sexuality (45)
Aboriginal People (42)
Facebook (36)
Australian Society (32)
Homosexuality (30)
Scholars (30)
Muslim (26)
Neuropsychology (26)
Historians (24)
Gambling (23)
Clive Hamilton (23)
Health (23)
Sociology (23)
Decision-making (22)
Alice Springs (21)
Parenting (19)
State Library of Victoria (18)
Climate change denialism (17)
Conservatism (17)
AFL (16)
CULTURE
Literature (152)
Fiction (145)
Hollywood (112)
Photography (111)
Memoir (108)
Arts (94)
Biography (88)
Painting (84)
Comedy (63)
Musicians (58)
Dance (54)
Philosophy (50)
Architecture (48)
Short Stories (31)
Art (25)
Cooking (24)
Autobiography (24)
20 Australian Masterpieces (22)
Jazz (21)
Film (20)
Modern Masterpieces (20)
Arts Masterpieces (20)
Aussie Masterpieces (20)
Top 20 Arts Masterpieces (20)
Australian Film (19)
Directors (16)
WORLD
China (213)
Iraq (115)
Afghanistan (70)
India (69)
Ireland (68)
World economy (60)
Britain (60)
Middle East (55)
Africa (54)
Asia (54)
Barack Obama (52)
New York City (50)
Egypt (45)
Pakistan (44)
New Zealand (44)
Russia (42)
World War II (42)
Foreign Policy (42)
Iran (37)
Eurozone (37)
New York Times (37)
Indonesia (37)
Italy (36)
European Union (34)
George W Bush (34)
Japan (33)
Terrorism (32)
Greece (28)
United Nations (28)
East Timor (26)
Taliban (25)
Libya (25)
Israel (23)
Arab Spring (23)
Communism (22)
Egyptian revolution (22)
Beijing (19)
Syria (18)
American Military (18)
Thailand (17)
Russian politics (17)
News International (17)
Libyan uprising (16)
Peak oil (16)
Saudi Arabia (16)
Nuclear power (16)
ENVIRONMENT
Climate Change (275)
Nuclear (146)
Drought (78)
Global Warming (58)
Sustainability (46)
Tasmania (44)
ETS (28)
Carbon dioxide (26)
Conservation (24)
Amazon (24)
Rainforest (20)
Emissions trading (20)
Carbon tax (17)
Carbon emissions (17)
Floods (16)
Ecology (16)
Nuclear Energy (16)
Water crisis (16)
ECONOMICS
Business (154)
Australian Economy (78)
The Global Financial Crisis (68)
European debt (55)
Finance (40)
Wall Street (39)
Global Financial Crisis (37)
Globalisation (37)
Global finance (36)
Recession (27)
Unemployment (20)
Food Production (20)
Population growth (17)
Stock Market (16)
MEDIA
ABC (108)
Journalism (94)
Australian Media (57)
Rupert Murdoch (55)
Radio National (41)
Quarterly Essay (40)
News Corporation (36)
Fairfax (35)
Google (33)
Wikileaks (28)
News Limited (26)
Twitter (25)
Social Media (25)
Communications (23)
Assange (23)
Guardian (23)
Phone-hacking scandal (22)
Julian Assange (19)
The Australian newspaper (18)
Crikey (17)
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Drugs (64)
Psychology (45)
Evolution (33)
Biology (28)
Disease (22)
Genetics (21)
Flu (17)